Monday, March 19, 2007

New Jersey AG, Consumer Affairs Director Warn Against Foreclosure Rescue Scams Involving "Surplus Funds"

New Jersey Attorney General Stuart Rabner and Acting Consumer Affairs Director Stephen B. Nolan recently issued a warning to New Jersey residents about a foreclosure rescue scam involving "surplus funds", the money that represents that portion of the sale proceeds of a foreclosure sale that is left over after the proceeds are first applied to paying off the amount owed to a foreclosing mortgage lender and, (apparently) in New Jersey, any unpaid real estate taxes, according to a Press Release from the New Jersey AG's office.

These surplus funds, also referred to as the "surplus money", "excess funds" or "overage" (and possibly other terms), represent the homeowner's equity in his/her home that they are entitled to claim after the foreclosure sale takes place. Therefore, and contrary to what some foreclosure rescue operators will falsely have people believe, when a homeowner loses his/her home in a foreclosure sale, the home equity, if any, is not necessarily lost. If the sale price exceeds the amount owed, the balance (ie. the surplus funds) is typically held in an account by the court that ordered the sale and it simply sits there until the homeowner comes forward and claims it (or until a scam artist comes forward, forges or otherwise tricks the homeowner into signing the necessary paperwork, and steals it - see, for example, Arrests Made in South Florida Foreclosure Scams, involving an alleged theft of foreclosure surplus funds that may have victimized at least 20 Florida homeowners).

Further, because of the significant increase in third party investors attending and bidding at these foreclosure sales throughout the U.S. over the last few years (in large part due to the spike in property values in many parts of the country during the early 2000's; in some part due to the "foreclosure investing" infomercials on late night cable TV), the sale prices at these foreclosure sales have typically come pretty close to full fair market value (unlike the old days when an investor could pick up a pretty good deal at a significant discount at these forced sales). As a result, it has been quite common for there to be surplus funds left over after a foreclosure sale took place and a foreclosing lender got paid off on its outstanding loan.

Due to the fact that many homeowners are unaware of their rights to the surplus money, a profit opportunity is open for both the ethical and the unethical to capitalize on the recovery of these surplus funds. This is the case in spite of the fact that, at least in New Jersey, homeowners can obtain the surplus funds on their own simply by filing a simple form and paying less than $100 (if you're a New Jersey resident, more information is available from the New Jersey Superior Court Trust Fund Unit at 609-292-3937; my guess is that other local court systems throughout the rest of the U.S. have some type of system for assisting homeowners recover their surplus funds).

The unethical and the con artists who have gotten into this area of foreclosure rescue have engaged in one of two forms of this scam (which can be thought of as a creative form of "equity stripping") and which are described in the Press Release. To read more, see Consumers Cautioned About “Surplus Funds” Scams Amid Rising Foreclosure Filings.

For concise, one page brochures warning against scams involving the surplus money left after a foreclosure sale, see:

To read about the recent legal action settled by the Washington State Attorney General against three foreclosure rescue operators involving a "surplus funds" scam, see More On AG McKenna's Settlement With Foreclosure Rescue Operators.

Click here to Watch the TV report on the Washington case on Channel 4 KOMO-TV

Editor's Note:

I suspect that, because of the general downturn in values in the real estate market recently, more and more lenders will be foreclosing on homes on which they're owed more than what the properties are worth; these properties are said to be "upside down". In these cases, the foreclosing mortgage lenders will be stuck buying these "upside down" properties themselves at a foreclosure auction or forced into allowing the properties to be sold to third party bidders at said auction for less than the amount owed. Accordingly, in these cases there will be no surplus funds for homeowners to claim.
(corrected 3-22-07)
.

1031 Exchange Accomodators, Others Accused in $80 Million Theft

A class action lawsuit has been filed in California against Donald Kay McGhan, 1031 exchange accommodators Southwest Exchange, of Nevada and Qualified Exchange Services, of Santa Barbara, and others containing allegations of theft of over $80 million from 130 people in 12 states, according to a report by the San Luis Obispo Tribune.

This civil lawsuit, filed by the Santa Barbara law firm of Hollister & Brace, claims the money was stolen in a scheme involving "1031" or "tax-free" exchanges of real estate. "1031" is a reference to a provision in the Federal tax law (Section 1031 of the Internal Revenue Code) that essentially says that, if you structure your transaction correctly, you can sell your investment real estate, take the proceeds and reinvest it in, what the tax law refers to as, property of a "like kind" without having to pay immediate capital gains taxes; the tax liability is deferred indefinitely. Part of structuring your transaction correctly involves the use of an independent third party intermediary to hold the sale proceeds from the sale of one property in trust until the reinvestment property is purchased.

The money that was allegedly stolen represents the proceeds of the alleged victims' sales of their investment real estate that was being held in trust by the intermediary and earmarked for reinvestment. Because the funds now aren't available for reinvestment, these investors have not only had their money stolen, but they are now ineligible for the indefinite deferral of their capital gains taxes allowed by the tax law. In other words, they will have to pay immediate capital gains taxes on the profits from their real estate sales and, hopefully for them, they have enough money from other sources to pay it.

Further, the lawsuit indicates that these investors had purchase contracts to buy property that the reinvestment proceeds were earmarked for. Because the money is now no longer available, the investors are liable for contractual damages to the sellers of the reinvestment property for defaulting on the purchase contracts.

Reportedly, the FBI is investigating the possibility of criminality. To read more, see Santa Barbara suit alleges ponzi scheme by breast implant pioneer. sneaky slick escrow agents gamma

Sunday, March 18, 2007

Florida Feds Get Guilty Pleas On Two In "Operation Whose House"

The U.S. Attorney's Office in Miami, Florida obtained guilty pleas this past week from Megan McGuire and Christine A. Brown, two members of an alleged 11 person mortgage fraud ring indicted in November, in connection with an investigation referred to as "Operation Whose House" by Federal investigators.

Authorities decribed the operation as a complex mortgage fraud scheme involving more than thirty (30) properties bought and sold in Broward County. The fraud resulted in the issuance of approximately $10,000,000 in mortgage loans.

According to authorities, the defendants devised a scheme to enrich themselves by obtaining mortgages from lenders using straw purchasers and through the submission of false documentation, including false loan applications, false employment verification forms, false salary statements, and false bank account statements reflecting high account balances. The defendants also used and caused others to use false or stolen Florida’s driver’s licenses, identification cards, and social security numbers as their personal identification at closings to purchase property in the names of individuals whose identification documents had been previously stolen.

To read more, see:
.

Straw Buyer, Equity Skimming Scam Claims Dozens Of Victims

(Orig. post 3-18-07; revised 6-12-07)
Dozens of victims have reportedly been sucked into the back end of a possible straw buyer scam, according to a report on KMBC-TV Channel 9 website, at TheKansasCityChannel.com. Reportedly, homes recently purchased by straw buyers were subsequently rented with an option to buy to the equity skimming scam victims. The victims unwittingly moved in to the homes, made some rent payments, and then found out that the homes were in foreclosure.

In one case, the straw buyer lives in Houston, and has several Kansas City homes in her name.

Dozens of homes have already been sold at foreclosure sales and later this month, more victims will lose their homes as well, according to the report. The FBI is investigating the possible link between the affected homes.

To read more, see Mortgage Scam Claims Dozens Of Victims (Northland Families Evicted From Homes)

For other stories on tenants unknowingly renting homes in foreclosure, go here, or here, or here. alpha
.

D.C. Resident Tricked Out Of Title To Home; Local Government Eyeing Legislation To Curb Foreclsoure Rescue Scams

The Washington D.C. City Council says it is crafting legislation that will curb foreclosure rescue scams and subprime mortgage money, according to a report on NBC4.com. To read more, including a story of a local resident who unwittingly signed away his home, see D.C. Officials Look To Help Homeowners Keep Homes.
.

Saturday, March 17, 2007

Congress Considering Clamp Down On Subprime Mortgage Market

The congressional subcommittee having oversight over financial institutions is scheduled later this month to hold a hearing in connection with the current misery in the subprime mortgage lending market, according to an Associated Press article reported by the Florida Association of Realtors on their website. Reportedly, executives from subprime lending firms could be called to testify at future hearings.

In addition, on the Senate side, Sen. Christopher Dodd, D-Conn., chairman of the Senate Banking Committee, issued a statement saying that he is “considering a number of options, including legislation” to protect consumers from abusive lending practices and help consumers who have been harmed to maintain their homes, according to the article. To read more, see:

Are FBI Mortgage Fraud Estimates Low?

Yes, by over $3 billion a year, according to Arthur Prieston, chairman of The Prieston Group, a California firm which offers an integrated suite of fraud protection, loss mitigation and insurance services. Another expert says it could even be more than that. In addition, practices such as "shotgunning" are reportedly on the upswing, and there is a belief that some home builders stuck with unsold homes may be next to utilize "straw buyer" scams to better facillitate unloading their inventory. Fraud by loan originators and title closers are also reportedly at unprecedented levels.

To read more, see Fraud: $4 Billion and Rising, reported in Realty Times.
.

Friday, March 16, 2007

Jury Acquits On Two Charges; Mistrial On Six Others In Peterson Pocono Case

A Pennsylvania jury, reportedly about to come to fisticuffs at one point, acquitted title closing agent Anita Peterson on two charges of lying under oath but ended up deadlocked on six others, including the five mortgage fraud charges of tampering with closing documents and one count of hindering prosecution, according to an article in the Pocono Record. A mistrial was declared as to the six charges and the prosecution promptly announced that it intends to retry Peterson on those counts. A new trial is to be scheduled in May.

To read more, see Jury hung in home fraud trial (Peterson acquitted on 2 charges; retrial set in 6 others)
.

More On AG McKenna's Settlement With Foreclosure Rescue Operators

For more information on Washington State Attorney General Rob McKenna's settlement agreement with three Washington-based foreclosure rescue operators, see:

Click here for other posts on State of Washington foreclosure rescue settlement.

(corrected 3-22-07)

.

South Carolina Woman Loses Home To Foreclosure Scam

A South Carolina woman was conned out of $1,000 in fees she paid to a foreclosure rescue consultant she thought was helping her avoid foreclosure, according to a report WLTX-TV Channel 19 in South Carolina. The con artist did nothing for her and the home ultimately sold at a foreclosure sale. For more, see:
.

Thursday, March 15, 2007

More On The Phil Hill Straw Buyer Flipping Trial

For additional information on the Atlanta, Georgia mortgage fraud trial involving Atlanta area real estate operator Phillip E. Hill, Sr. and others, see:

Click here for prior posts on the Phillip Hill case.

.

Three Foreclosure Rescue Operators Settle Charges With Washington State AG

(revised 6-8-07)
Washington Attorney General Rob McKenna has announced a settlement reached with three foreclosure rescue operators accused of taking advantage of financially distressed homeowners, according to the Press Release issued by the AG's office. They have also announced the filing of civil charges against two other individuals involved in the matter.

Fiscal Dynamics, Inc. and Cumulative LLC, of Tacoma; and Northwest Assets, of Seattle, have agreed pay a total of $290,000 in consumer restitution. Walt Scamehorn, owner of Fiscal Dynamics and Cumulative, and E. Arliss Morgan, owner of Northwest, have also agreed to the terms of the settlement. While agreeing to make the settlement, all those charged have denied wrongdoing.

The operators were charged, in a civil lawsuit filed by the AG in December, with unfair or deceptive acts or practices involving "overage plays" (attempts to scam homeowners out of the surplus money, or "overage" that results when the proceeds of a foreclosure sale exceeds the amount owed to the foreclosing mortgagee), "partial interest trusts", and abuses and omissions when undertaking to act as a fiduciary. In addition, they were also accused of colluding to manipulate sale prices at a public auction and deceptive advertising.

Reportedly, more than 100 consumers may be entitled to receive restitution.

The new charges filed by the AG's office are against Joseph Kaiser, of Tacoma, and Tina Worthey, of Burien.

To read more, see the Washington AG's Press Release.

Click here for a copy of the Civil Complaint - State of Washington vs. Fiscal Dynamics, Inc., et al. (Describes in detail the nature of the alleged conduct)

See also Washington Attorney General Sues, Settles with Real Estate Investors for Mortgage Foreclosure "Rescue" Violations, report on All American Patriots news service.

See also 3 'foreclosure rescue' firms agree to settle, reported by the Seattle Post-Intelligencer.

Note:
Thanks to the Washington AG's office for making their civil complaint available online.
.

Another Minnesota Title Closer Charged In Mortgage Fraud

A continuing federal investigation has resulted in charges against Prior Lake mortgage broker Ronald Joseph, who was indicted this week in Minneapolis Federal Court. He is charged with two counts of mail fraud, one count of wire fraud and one count of money laundering. He is accused of devising a scheme to conceal $2.5 million in payments to himself, real estate buyers and other individuals through approximately 40 transactions, using fraudulent loan applications and settlement statements. The documents reflected inflated sale prices for the properties so that Joseph and others could pocket the difference.

Convicted mortgage closing agent Jill Lehn, also of Prior Lake, closed mortgages for both Joseph and another loan officer, Mario Lewis. Lewis, who received nearly $400,000, recently pleaded guilty to charges of wire fraud and money laundering.

To read more, see Prior Lake broker indicted in fake mortgage deals, reported by the Star Tribune.

See also Two more indicted in mortgage probe (Both suspects worked at LHS in Burnsville) in the Pioneer Press at twincities.com.

(articles no longer available online).

For story update (12/28/07), see Lender gets prison time (First in LHS case took plea) ("The first of four defendants tied to the LHS Mortgage Inc. fraud scandal was sentenced Friday to 4½ years in prison. Mario Lewis, 37, a loan officer at the LHS office in Burnsville, had pleaded guilty to drug charges, wire fraud and money laundering. Judge John Tunheim also ordered Lewis on Friday to pay restitution of $437,000. Lewis pocketed almost that much money from nine properties he bought in the Twin Cities area between 2004 and 2006.").

Wednesday, March 14, 2007

Hill Guilty Of 166 Counts In Straw Buyer Flipping Scam

The verdict in the Atlanta Federal Court flipping trial is now in. Atlanta real estate operator Phillip Hill (aka Phil Hill) has been found guilty by a jury on 166 counts of mortgage fraud. Nine co-defendants have also been found guilty on a number of counts. All but Hill have bonded out and are free pending appeals. Also convicted on charges including conspiracy, loan fraud, mail and wire fraud and money laundering were: Leslie Rector, David Van Mersbergen, Marcus C. Alcindor, Barbara Brown, Fred Farmer, Christine Laudermill, Robert Powers, David Thomas, and Dean Thomas.

To read more, see:

Click here for prior posts on the Phillip Hill case.

(revised 10-19-07)
.

Group Calls For Swift Strengthening Of Foreclosure Prevention Programs

The Center for American Progress is calling on policymakers to consider swiftly strengthening state and federal programs to stem the rising tide of home foreclosures, according to their report, From Boom to Bust - Helping Families Prepare for the Rise in Subprime Mortgage Foreclosures, that they recently issued. Among other things, the report lists some areas that have some form of mortgage assistance programs. To read more, see:

For free foreclosure prevention and intervention services, see NeighborWorks National Toll Free Hotline (1-888-995-HOPE) or www.995hope.org.

.

Connecticut Attorney Sentenced For Stealing From Clients

Former Fairfield, Connecticut attorney John M. Claydon Jr. was sentenced to five years in prison followed by three years special probation and restitution of $733,000 in a Connecticut Federal Court on Monday, accorfding to a story on The Connecticut Post Online. He pleaded guilty in December to one count of bank fraud for cheating clients out of money.

Claydon, prosecuted separately in Connecticut state court as well for cheating other clients, is expected to get another 15 years in prison and be ordered to pay $2.8 million in restitution when he is sentenced for those crimes later this month.

All told, he cheated 36 clients out of at least $3.9 million in real estate transactions in which his victims included individuals cheated out of home sale proceeds, banks, and a title insurance underwriter who had to pay out $720,000 in insurance claims as a result of Claydon's actions.

To read more, see Millions stolen by lawyer.

Click here for stories of other Connecticut attorneys in potential hot water.
.

Tuesday, March 13, 2007

Ohio Prosecutor Announces Two Arrests In Home Equity Theft Cases

Cuyahoga County Prosecutor Bill Mason has gotten off to a pretty fast start this year with real estate related fraud prosecutions as he announced two more indictments today, running up his totals to at two cases a month this year, involving 98 defendants, according to a story on The Plain Dealer blog, at blog.cleveland.com. The charges this year involve fraud cases totaling over $5 million in loans and 47 houses in 14 communities, according to the prosecutor's office.

Today's announcement involves two cases alleging blatant thefts of the victims' homes.

In one case, mortgage people Sammy Quick and Brian Cicerchi were allegedly approached by one victim interested in refinancing her home. They are accused of tricking her out of her title, stealing $56,000 in home equity, and then attempting to evict her.

In another case, Willard Horne Jr. of Norfolk, Virginia is accused of conning an 87-year-old Cleveland woman out of her home and $85,000.

For all the details, see Cuyahoga prosecutor presses predatory lending cases.
.

Accused Pennsylvania Title Agent Testifies In Her Own Defense

Anita Peterson, a title closing agent and former owner of Mountain Valley Abstract, took the stand in her own defense Monday on the fourth day of her trial where she is accused of intentionally falsifying dollar amounts on sales records, removing other documents from files, and lying about it to a state grand jury, according to a story in the Pocono Record, at poconorecord.com. To read more, including links to prior stories in this case, see Home-sale title agent defends self in fraud trial.
.

Three Sentenced In Georgia Mortgage Fraud

Three men involved in a mortgage fraud scam that cost victims over $1 million were sentenced to prison in a Georgia Federal Court yesterday, according to a story in The Augusta Chronicle at augustachronicle.com.

Stacey L. Shefton (48 months and $1.06 million restitution for wire fraud), Michael D. Dunn (51 months and $338,084 restitution for mail fraud), and Willie J. Anderson, Jr. (five years probation and $17,530 restitution for concealing the crimes of others) all avoided more serious prison time. According to an assistant U.S. Attorney familiar with the case, the crimes all occurred before before Congress increased the maximum punishment for mortgage fraud to 20 years in prison. To read more, see Three sentenced in $1.06 million fraud.
.

Daughter Gets 9 Months In Jail For Stealing $93K From Mother

A Las Vegas, Nevada woman was reportedly sentenced to nine months in jail for stealing $93,000 of her mother's money while her mother was in a New Hampshire nursing home, according to a report at Foster's Online, of Dover, New Hampshire. The money represented the proceeds from the sale of the mother's property. The daughter reportedly paid back the money prior to sentencing. For more, see Daughter sentenced in theft of $93,000 from mother.
.

Connecticut Lawyer In Trouble For Alleged Theft Of Realty Sale Proceeds

Peter Sivaslian, an ex-Torrington, Connecticut attorney, already facing trouble as a defendant "[i]n criminal and civil cases for allegedly stealing more than $2 million from an elderly client was arraigned Monday for an alleged theft from a second elderly client", according to a report by The Register Citizen, at registercitizen.com.

Sivaslian is alleged to have diverted $120,000 from his client's (a 90 year old widow) bank account through his own bank account and ultimately into his Oppenheimer & Company investment account. The $120,000 represents part of the sale proceeds from the sale of his client's real estate. It has also been alleged that he may have also used his client's investment account to hide $410,000 in bearer bonds.

In the earlier case, in October 2005, police searched Sivaslian's home and discovered 192 bearer bonds in his den, 163 of which authorities concluded were bought with money from the estate of another elderly client.

In the current case, an Oppenheimer & Company branch manager, being aware of the prior legal trouble Sivaslian was in, alertly contacted the cops when he (Sivaslian) showed up with the second client at Oppenheimer's Torrington branch and attempted to deposit $410,000 in bearer bonds in the second client's account.

For the rest of the details, see Attorney accused of more theft.

Click here for other posts on attorneys in potential hot water.
.