Wednesday, June 02, 2010

Mess Caused By Sloppy Lenders, Foreclosure Mills Deepens In Florida As Ambiguity In Recent State High Court Ruling Adds Confusion To Legal Process

In Central Florida, the Sarasota Herald Tribune reports:
  • An attempt to fix the sloppy legal work plaguing thousands of foreclosure cases in Florida has been ineffective, and has now caused a legal mess of its own. The Florida Supreme Court got tough on attorneys for banks and lenders in February, responding to stories of homeowners losing their property based on shoddy or incomplete paperwork. The incomplete filings also wasted judicial resources and clogged up the courts.

  • To combat that, a new rule enacted by the high court requires the attorney or bank filing a foreclosure to verify -- under penalty of perjury -- that the allegations and paperwork are accurate when a residential property is at stake. But attorneys have not followed the rule. Some contend they do not have to, arguing that the Supreme Court said the rule was not in effect yet.

***

  • A court-sanctioned review of hundreds of residential foreclosure filings in Sarasota and Manatee counties -- unofficially dubbed "Stop the Slop" -- found that nearly all the lawsuits lacked basic documentation. Of the 52 cases in the first round of review in Sarasota, all lacked the new verification requirement or other proof the bank is entitled to take the property, an attorney who reviewed the cases says. Backed by local Chief Judge Lee Haworth, who served on the state task force that recommended the new rule, judges in Manatee and Sarasota counties used the new rule to throw out dozens of foreclosure complaints in the past month.

  • But Miami attorney [Gerald] Richman, who represents banks and lenders, contacted Haworth last week and told him he and the other judges were jumping the gun. The confusion results from the wording of the Supreme Court's ruling. [...] The confusion sent Haworth backpedaling last week, after Richman said his client would appeal the tossing of the cases. Haworth temporarily suspended that part of the "Stop the Slop" program Friday, saying he was not alone in having questions.

***

  • Foreclosure defense attorneys had already pointed to Haworth's "Stop the Slop" program as an example that should be followed across the state. Haworth said he will continue policing foreclosure documents aside from the Supreme Court verification requirements.

For the story, see Legal mess over foreclosures deepening.