Mortgage Broker Gets 3 Years For Illegally Pocketing $16K By Filing Phony Mechanics Lien On Home Shortly Before Title Closing

In Jacksonville, Florida, The Florida Times Union reports:

• A Jacksonville mortgage broker faces three years in prison for pocketing thousands of dollars at a real estate closing by pretending she did home repairs. Katina Mickens, 30, was sentenced [...] for grand theft, filing a false construction lien claim and acting as an unlicensed real estate agent at a 2005 home sale where she arranged the mortgage.

***

• The day before the house went to closing, Mickens filed a document called a claim of lien. Under a fictitious name, J&J Properties, Mickens reported she had done work on the house and was owed $16,000. That represented about 18 percent of the $85,000 mortgage on the home, putting an unnecessary added burden on the buyer, [Assistant State Attorney Stephen] Siegel said.(1)

Source: Mortgage broker faces 3 years on theft charges (4th story from the top).

Go here for other posts on suspected mechanics lien scams.

(1) Reportedly, J&J Properties filed lien claims at six Jacksonville homes in 2004 and 2005, claiming to be owed a total of $117,835. Former owners of five of those properties said they never hired Mickens or J&J to do any repairs, and none was done, according to the story. A hearing is scheduled in July about other charges involving some of those homes, Siegel said. MechanicLienScamTheta

Arrest Warrant Issued For Unlicensed California Contractor Suspected Of Illegally Slapping Phony Mechanics Liens On Homes In Foreclosure

In Vallejo, California, the Vallejo Times Herald reports:

• A $30,000 arrest warrant has been issued for a Benicia man who officials believe has been trying to profit illegally from Vallejo's foreclosure crisis. A team from the Solano County District Attorney's Office and Vallejo Police Department on Wednesday went to arrest James Paul Jones in the Vallejo home he's been occupying and found him gone, said Deputy District Attorney Laura Undlin.

• Jones, 53, also known as James King and King James, is suspected of contracting without a license and filing false or forged documents, Undlin said. The false document charge is a felony, she said.

• Jones has filed mechanic's liens against several foreclosed Vallejo homes he claims to have done work on for which he wasn't paid.(1) [...] Reached by phone Friday, Jones appeared surprised to hear about the warrant, and insists he's done nothing wrong.(2)

For the rest of the story, see Man trying to cash in on foreclosures, officials say.

Go here for other posts on suspected mechanics lien scams.

(1) If Jones actually did what he is suspected of doing, he possibly felt that having the mechanics liens would facilitate a claim on his part to all or part of any surplus funds generated by a subsequent foreclosure sale, in the event the home sold at auction for more than what was owed to the foreclosing lender.

(2) Reportedly, in one case, Jones seems to have contracted for $40,000 worth of water damage repairs with a relative of Jones's who owned the property before it was foreclosed on, according to Deputy DA Undlin. Jones is then said to have then filed a $75,000 mechanics lien six days later. "We don't believe that such extensive work could be done in six days, and, in fact, we have a witness that says he saw work being done for six to eight weeks after the lien was filed," Undlin said. StiffingContractorsTheta MechanicLienScamTheta

Mass AG: Firm Agrees To Remove Mechanics Liens On Houses; Resolves Complaints By Paid-In Full Homeowners Of Improper Squeezing By Contractor, Supplier

From the Office of the Massachusetts Attorney General:

• Attorney General Martha Coakley’s Office has entered into a settlement agreement with [...] National Lumber Company resolving a civil investigation into National Lumber’s placement of liens on the homes of at least ten Massachusetts consumers totaling approximately $260,000, as well as National Lumber’s business relationship with Taunton-based home improvement contractor Dennis Bartel (“Bartel”) and Bartel’s companies New Dimensions Construction Services and New Dimensions Construction, LLC . [...] National Lumber has agreed to remove all liens placed on Massachusetts residential properties where National Lumber was seeking to recover monies for labor and/or materials it had supplied to Bartel and New Dimensions.

***

• The Attorney General’s Office began investigating Bartel in 2005, after receiving complaints from Massachusetts consumers alleging, among other unfair conduct, that Bartel, through his home contracting businesses, executed contracts and took payments for home improvements and failed to either commence or complete the projects. Bartel allegedly also failed to pay National Lumber for the materials for which the consumers had prepaid.

***

• The Attorney General’s Office received complaints that National Lumber, a subcontractor for Bartel, was placing liens on the homes of Massachusetts consumers to assist Bartel in leveraging payments from these consumers even though the consumers claimed not to owe additional monies to Bartel.

• The Attorney General’s Office also investigated allegations that National Lumber's liens exceeded the amount owed for materials and that National Lumber extended credit to Bartel, despite his payment delinquency, with the intention of placing these liens to recover from the consumers the monies due from Bartel.

For more, see the Mass AG press release: AG Coakley Reaches Agreement with Lumber Company to Remove Liens Placed on Consumers’ Property for Monies Owed by Contractor.

For a similar sounding alleged scam in Illinois, see Attorney General Madigan, State's Attorney Alvarez Sue Chicago Lien Filing Service For Fraudulent Practices.

Go here for other posts on suspected mechanics lien scams. StiffingContractorsTheta MechanicLienScamTheta

Illinois AG, Cook County SA Say Firm Filed Phony Mechanics Liens & Started Foreclosure On Homeowners Refusing To Be Squeezed

From the Office of the Illinois Attorney General:

• Attorney General Lisa Madigan and Cook County State’s Attorney Anita Alvarez [Wednesday] both filed lawsuits against a Chicago mechanic’s lien filing service for filing invalid liens against property owners and for intimidating homeowners either to pay debts they don’t owe or to overpay for debts incurred with contractors.

***

• According to the Attorney General’s complaint, Contractor’s Lien Services (CLS) and its founder, Steve Boucher, analyze, prepare and file mechanic’s liens on property on behalf of general contractors and subcontractors. CLS allegedly misrepresents to contractors that it has valid cause for filing mechanics liens against homeowners when, most often, those contractors do not actually have valid claims under state laws.

• CLS also allegedly files liens without the knowledge of some contractors and, in other instances, CLS files liens against homeowners when contractors have not performed work at the properties in question.

• After filing foreclosure liens, CLS allegedly files foreclosure actions against consumers who don’t pay off the debts. Some contractors claim that CLS collects money on behalf of contractors but then fails to redistribute the collected debts to them.

For the Illinois AG press release, see Attorney General Madigan, State's Attorney Alvarez Sue Chicago Lien Filing Service For Fraudulent Practices.

For what sounds like a similar matter recently resolved by the Massachusetts Attorney General's Office, see Mass AG: Firm Agrees To Remove Mechanics Liens On Houses (Resolves Complaints By Paid-In Full Homeowners Of Improper Squeezing By Contractor, Supplier).

Go here for other posts on suspected mechanics lien scams. StiffingContractorsTheta MechanicLienScamTheta