Tuesday, April 07, 2015

Landlords To Fork Over $19K Plus Tenant's Legal Fees To Resolve Allegations That They Squeezed Section 8 Tenant For Excessive Rent Disguised As Trash Removal Fees; Use Of Whistleblower Provisions Of Federal False Claims To Blow Whistle On Landlord Will Allow Renter To Share In Settlement Proceeds

From the Office of the U.S. Attorney (Philadelphia, Pennsylvania):
  • The United States Attorney's Office announced today that Bellante Properties, of Lehigh County, PA, and its owners Vincent Fantozzi and Bernard Fantozzi, will pay the government $19,120 to resolve allegations surrounding federally-funded rental assistance payments it received. According to a civil complaint, Bellante Properties received rent subsidy payments from the Lehigh County Housing Authority while unlawfully requiring a tenant to pay supplemental rental payments disguised as trash removal fees.

    The lawsuit was filed by Karen Schware, in the United States District Court for the Eastern District of Pennsylvania, under the whistleblower provisions of the False Claims Act. The False Claims Act allows private citizens to bring civil actions on behalf of the United States and to share in any recovery.

    The Section 8 housing assistance program is designed to provide affordable housing to low-income families. According to the government’s complaint, between July 2007 and September 2013, Bellante Properties received payments from the Lehigh County Housing Authority under the Section 8 rent assistance program. In addition to receiving federally-funded Section 8 rent assistance payments, and approved rent payments from the tenant, the government alleges that Bellante Properties also unlawfully required the tenant to provide supplemental rent payments that had not been approved by the Lehigh County Housing Authority.

    The unlawful supplemental payments were disguised as trash removal fees. The parties have agreed to settle the dispute for a payment by the defendants of $19,120 to the United States. Bellante Properties and its principals, Vincent Fantozzi and Bernard Fantozzi, are also barred for three years from participation in HUD’s Section 8 program. As a whistleblower, Schware will receive a share of the settlement proceeds. Bellante Properties will also pay Schware’s legal fees.

    The settlement was the result of a coordinated effort by the U.S. Attorney’s Office for the Eastern District of Pennsylvania and the Department of Housing and Urban Development Office of Inspector General. The case was handled by Assistant U.S. Attorney Joel M. Sweet.
Source: United States Settles With Lehigh County Landlord Over Section 8 Rent Subsidy Payments.

For the whistleblower lawsuit complaint in intervention filed by the Feds, see USA ex. rel. Schware v. Fantozzi. (Note: The original suit was filed on behalf of the tenant by Community Justice Project ("CJP"), Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania and North Penn Legal Services, Bethlehem, Pennsylvania. Both firms are nonprofit legal services organizations providing civil legal aid to low-income residents of Pennsylvania. In addition, CJP is an “unrestricted” legal services program, working on issues and cases that traditional non-profit legal services organizations cannot handle (ie. litigating class actions, representing undocumented immigrants, and litigating against the government).

For an earlier story involving the use of federal whistleblower suits against landlords accusing them of violating Section 8 rules, see Miami Non-Profit Law Firm, Local Feds Join To Score Wins In Two Novel Whistleblower Suits Accusing Local Landlords Of Illegally Squeezing Gov't, Section 8 Tenants Out Of Excessive Rent Subsidies; $uccessful Recovery Includes Tenants' Damages, Legal Fees.

Monday, July 23, 2007

Whistleblower Suit Accuses Lender Of Defrauding Government Out Of Millions

A whistleblower lawsuit has been bouncing around in a Brooklyn, New York Federal Court since May, 2005 in which four "whistleblowers" accused M & T Mortgage Corp., a subsidiary of M & T Banking Corp., of "knowingly and recklessly present[ing] fraudulent claims for millions of dollars to the United States Department of Housing and Urban Development (HUD) for ... mortgage insurance claims on properties ... after recklessly taking assignments of forged, and therefore, void mortgages thereon, after knowing that the mortgages were forged ..."

Among other accusations in the original lawsuit is the claim that inflated mortgages, for which no funds were actually advanced, were written and forged, and then assigned to banks for the purpose of defrauding HUD.

A recent (July 9, 2007) press release reports on what is apparently an updated development in the case:
  • "The whistle blower suit stems from a case involving more than 50 mortgages owned by M & T on properties in Manhattan and Brooklyn that were fraudulently secured through HUD's 203K program for non-profits. A new admission by M & T's lawyer reveals there are nearly 400 fraudulent mortgages worth a half-billion dollars. Indeed, on Friday night, June 29, 2007, Todd Marcus, the attorney for M & T, admitted in a letter to the court that his client never made him aware of a secretive deal between the bank and HUD, in which HUD agreed to pay off not just these 50 fraudulent mortgages, but an astonishing total of 374 fraudulent mortgages worth some $500 million! Marcus previously represented to the court that M & T had no knowledge of any fraud in the origination of any of these loans. The deal between M & T was reached six years ago, according to a letter dated January 11, 2001. Although his law partner attended the meeting at which the deal was reached, Marcus told the court on Friday that he was not aware of the agreement or even the letter's existence until April of this year!"
The press release quotes the plaintiff's attorney, Peter S. Gordon, as saying "[The] admission to the court by M & T attorney Todd Marcus concerning these 50 fraudulent mortgages, as well as the 324 other ones, not only propels the whistle-blower lawsuit forward, but could also result in a number of criminal indictments."

For more, see:

1) Copy of Federal whistleblower lawsuit - Pugatch, et al. vs. M & T Mortgage Corp.

2) July 9, 2007 Press Release - M & T Bank Subject of Whistle Blower Lawsuit; Bank Accused of Defrauding Government Out of Millions From Forged Mortgages (from Earthtimes.org) or (from PR Newswire).

3) Go here for other posts on whistleblower suits involving alleged fraudulent mortgage lending practices.

Monday, February 16, 2009

More On World Savings' Whistleblower Paul Bishop

On CBS News' The Early Show this morning, World Savings whistleblower Paul Bishop spoke with Harry Smith about when he first noticed the company was taking on unstable loans. The interview was a follow-up on last night's 60 Minutes story in which Bishop described the kinds of mortgage loans his former employer was making, and how they were making them.

For today's interview (about 5 minutes), see Mortgage Whistleblower.

For last night's story (13+ minutes), see World of Trouble (read story) (watch video).

Go here for other posts on whistleblower suits alleging fraudulent mortgage lending practices.

Monday, March 19, 2012

Whistleblowers Score Million$ In Seperate Suits Targeting Duibious Bankster Mortgage Lending, Foreclosure Practices

ProPublica reports:
  • Buried in the sweeping mortgage settlement with banks, for which final documents were filed this week, are five whistleblower cases that shed light on the litany of foreclosure abuses by the banks.


  • According to one suit, Bank of America allegedly passed bad loans on to the Federal Housing Administration. According to another, the bank allegedly denied qualified homeowners access to HAMP, the government's loan modification program.


  • The suits were all settled as part of the overall $25 billion mortgage deal. They were filed under the False Claims Act, which provides incentives for whistleblowers to come forward in cases in which someone has defrauded the government. Whistleblowers can net up to 25 percent of the total settlement from False Claims suits, and in some of these cases, the reward is in the millions.


  • Details are available for four of the cases; documents in a fifth, against JPMorgan Chase, have not yet been filed in Massachusetts. While the cases were settled as part of the overarching agreement, they still have to be accepted by the courts in which they were originally filed. In reaching the settlements, none of the banks admits or denies the lawsuits' allegations. We've laid out the details of each case.

***

  • [Kyle] Lagow's suit was settled for $75 million, and was a component of the FHA's $1 billion settlement with Bank of America over FHA insurance. Documents detailing his cut of the $75 million haven't yet been filed. [... Lynn Szymoniak's] suit was settled for $95 million, and she will receive $18 million. [...] [A] JPMorgan [lawsuit] settled for $45 million. The two whistleblowers, Victor Bibby and Brian Donnelly, told Reuters that together they would receive $11 million. They also said they would continue their case against the other banks. [...] [A Bank of America] suit was settled for $6.5 million, and [whistleblower Gregory] Mackler's cut has not been finalized.

For more, see Four Whistleblowers Who Sounded the Alarm on Banks’ Mortgage Shenanigans.

See also, Reuters: Whistleblowers reap millions in U.S. mortgage suits.

Wednesday, December 12, 2007

Investigator Fired For Pushing Probe Into Bogus Loans & Refusing To Participate In Bank Coverup, Says Lawsuit

In North Carolina, The Charlotte Observer reports:
  • BB&T, North Carolina's third-largest bank, vigorously denied charges Friday that a former internal investigator for the company was fired for refusing to participate in the coverup of a $20 million loan fraud. Amy Stroupe, who filed a lawsuit against the company [last] week, said she was fired for pursuing an investigation of more than 120 fraudulent real estate loans. The loans were connected to a failed development in Western North Carolina known as the Village of Penland that left investors owing banks about $120 million.
***
  • Stroupe, a former sheriff's detective who was hired in 2005, was fired June 20. She alleged in her suit that she pushed her investigation of Penland because many of the loan applications used the same loan officer, appraiser, attorney and picture of what appeared to be the same mountain lot. The lots were often appraised for more than market value and sold to people who had never visited the site or met the loan officer, the suit said.

For more, see BB&T denies unfair firing (if link expires, try here).

Representing Amy Stroupe in her lawsuit is attorney John Yanchunis, with the law firm James, Hoyer, Newcomer & Smiljanich PA., Tampa, Florida. (According to their website, the firm has a nationwide practice handling whistleblower cases, and consumer cases, - including mortgage servicing problem cases - among other cases.)

------------------

The lawsuit referred to in this story is the second reported within a month alleging BB&T Bank's involvement in a sophisticated fraud in connection with the Village of Penland project. For the earlier story, see 2 N.C. banks accused in fraud suit (Investors owe millions of dollars on N.C. mountain property worth much less) (The Charlotte Observer).

For background information on the souring of the Village of Penland project that left investors holding the bag, see The Wall Street Journal article, 'I Feel Like an Idiot' (Land Project Gone Wrong Shows How Even Well-Off Lured By Go-Go Climate) (May be a free article; if not, try here).

Go here for other posts on the Village of Penland.

Go here for other posts on whistleblower suits involving alleged fraudulent mortgage lending practices. Tony Porter

Thursday, February 07, 2008

Another Employee Allegedly Canned For Disclosing Fraudulent Lending Practices Files Whistleblower Lawsuit

The Associated Press reports:
  • A former employee of Countrywide KB Home Loans has filed a lawsuit claiming he was wrongly fired after he reported fraudulent lending practices to superiors and refused to approve mortgages for unqualified applicants. The federal lawsuit was brought by Mark Zachary, a regional vice president and manager of the Countrywide KB Home Loans division in Houston. He seeks unspecified compensatory and punitive damages against the joint venture of mortgage lender Countrywide Financial Corp. and builder KB Home.

***

  • In the suit, Zachary contended he was given an excellent performance review last February then fired three months later after he blew the whistle on fellow employees and outlined instances in which appraisers were "being strongly encouraged to inflate homes' appraised value by as much as 6 percent." That resulted in buyers owing more than their home was worth, Zachary claimed in the lawsuit filed Jan. 17 in U.S. District Court in the Southern District of Texas. [...] Zachary said he was fired after he failed to meet a quota for new loan approvals because he refused to clear unqualified applicants, according to the complaint.

For more, see Fired Worker Sues KB Home, Countrywide.

Go here for other posts on whistleblower suits involving alleged fraudulent mortgage lending practices.

Sunday, February 15, 2009

CBS' 60 Minutes On World Savings' Whistleblower

CBS' 60 Minutes ran a story Sunday night featuring the story of Paul Bishop, a plainspoken former loan salesman who is blowing the whistle on his former employer, one-time subprime lending giant World Savings, about the kinds of loans they were making to homeowners who couldn't afford to repay, and how they went about making the loans. While working at World, he reportedly told executives what they didn't want to hear about three years before the real estate market exploded. According to him, they responded by canning him. He has since filed a lawsuit against them. He now tells his story to 60 Minutes.

For the report (13+ minutes), see World of Trouble (read story) (watch video).

For the initial report on this story from KPIX-TV Channel 5 in May, 2008, when Bishop first filed his lawsuit against World Savings, see Oakland Bank's Lending Sparks Ex-Employee Lawsuit (read story) (watch video).

Go here for other posts on whistleblower suits involving alleged fraudulent mortgage lending practices.

Sunday, May 26, 2013

Miami Non-Profit Law Firm, Local Feds Join To Score Wins In Two Novel Whistleblower Suits Accusing Local Landlords Of Illegally Squeezing Gov't, Section 8 Tenants Out Of Excessive Rent Subsidies; $uccessful Recovery Includes Tenants' Damages, Legal Fees

From the Office of the U.S. Attorney (Miami, Florida):
  • Wifredo A. Ferrer, United States Attorney for the Southern District of Florida, and Marcia K. Cypen, Executive Director, Legal Services of Greater Miami, Inc. (LSGMI),(1) announced the United States’ successful prosecution of several civil False Claims Act cases brought under the qui tam provisions of the False Claims Act, 31 U.S.C. §3730(b) against landlords participating in the United States Department of Housing and Urban Development’s (HUD) Housing Choice Voucher/Section 8 (HCV) Program who unlawfully received excessive rent subsidies known as Housing Assistance Payments (HAP).

    Through Section 8 of the United States Housing Act of 1937, as amended, HUD distributes federal funds to local public housing agencies to assist eligible low income families in obtaining decent, safe, and sanitary housing in the private rental market. To receive federally subsidized rents, landlords participating in the HCV Program contractually agree to comply with HUD requirements, to charge only the rent authorized by the local public housing agency and to not raise rents or change lease terms without the written approval of the local public housing agency.

    Two of the False Claims Act cases were originally filed by LSGMI who represented Sabrina R. Newberry and Taronda Wade, two low income tenants participating in the HCV Program administered by the Miami-Dade Public Housing and Community Development, a department of Miami-Dade County previously known as the Miami-Dade Public Housing Agency.

    The tenants brought the cases on behalf of the United States alleging that their landlords, the defendants, made unlawful false claims for rental subsidies by charging and accepting excessive rents, in violation of HUD rules and contractual requirements.

    After investigating the cases, the United States intervened in the two suits. The United States filed amended complaints asserting that the landlords violated the False Claims Act by making false statements to the County’s HCV Program and endorsing HAP rent subsidy checks for which the United States suffered damages.
------------------------------
  • 1. United States of America, ex rel Sabrina R . Newberry, Relator, Plaintiffs, v. George David Horton, Defendant, Case No. 1:11-cv-20153-Graham.

    According to court documents, during her brief tenancy, Newberry’s landlord, the Rev. Dr. George David Horton, collected $5,377.32 in rent from Ms. Newberry in excess of that specified in the HAP Contract and the rental agreement approved by the County’s HCV Program. A settlement was reached in this matter after the United States filed a Motion for Summary Judgment.

    There, the landlord who denied wrongdoing, paid to the United States $26,000 of which Ms. Newberry received, pursuant to the provisions of the False Claims Act, a Relator’s share of $5,377.32 and recovery of her legal expenses.

    During its investigation of the matter, the United States learned that Rev. Dr. Horton had also accepted at least $19,169.00 in excessive rents from another HCV tenant over a long period of time. In settlement of that matter, the landlord agreed to pay to the United States an additional $24,000.00.
--------------------------------
  • 2. United States of America, ex. rel. Taronda Wade, Relator, vs. DBS Investments, LLC, and John P. Joseph, 1:11-cv-20155-Cooke.

    Court documents provide that Ms. Wade’s landlord, DBS Investments and John P. Joseph, unlawfully charged and accepted $4,398.00 more than Ms. Wade was lawfully required to pay during her tenancy.

    U.S. District Judge Marcia Cooke granted the United States’ motion for summary judgment in this matter and entered an award against the Defendants and in favor of the United States of $35,194.00, consisting of damages in the amount of $13,194.00 and penalties of $22,000. The Court additionally entered an award of $4,398.00 in damages, $10,470.00 in attorney’s fees and $152.35 in costs to Ms. Wade.

    U.S. Attorney Wifredo A. Ferrer stated, “We will not tolerate abuse of federal housing or other programs. Schemes such as the ones uncovered in these cases steal taxpayers’ monies and often prey on those who need our assistance the most. We appreciate the actions of Legal Services of Greater Miami in bringing these cases and applaud whistleblowers for coming forward and exposing these schemes. We are pleased to return these monies to the taxpayers.”

    “This is not only a legal victory for low-income tenants but also serves as a deterrent to other landlords who do not comply with federal housing requirements,” said LSGMI Senior Staff Attorney Sean Rowley. Added Mr. Rowley, “This case also illustrates how the novel use of the False Claims Act to challenge illegal conduct by landlords can be a highly effective legal strategy and can serve as precedent for other public housing tenant advocates.”

    Mr. Ferrer commended LSGM and Miami-Dade Public Housing and Community Development for their assistance and investigative efforts. These cases were prosecuted by Assistant U.S. Attorney James A. Weinkle.
For the U.S. Attorney press release, see United States Successful In False Claims Act Cases Against Landlords Charging Housing Choice Voucher Tenants Excess Rents.

For the False Claims Act quit tam complaints filed by Legal Services of Greater Miami, Inc. on behalf of the United States and its 'Section 8' clients, see:
(1) Legal Services of Greater Miami, Inc. is a non-profit legal services provider that handles a variety of civil legal matters benefiting more than 30,000 individuals and families each year. In most cases, eligibility for services is based on an annual income at or below 125% of the federal poverty guidelines.

Sunday, July 13, 2008

Ex-World Savings Loan Originator Sues Company For Retaliation For Reporting Alleged Improper Lending Practices

In Oakland, California, a story originally aired by KPIX-TV Channel 5 in May reports:
  • A former employee of Oakland's World Savings is suing the company (now owned by Wachovia) and its former principals, saying he was fired in retaliation for his reporting of improper practices and violations of state and federal laws [...] by World in selling loans in San Francisco and the Bay Area.

***

  • In the complaint, [ex-loan consultant Paul] Bishop claims World "preyed upon" desperate borrowers who were "enticed into bad/predatory loans…without being told the complete truth about the loans" and that "borrowers were not told the full story about the terms, assumptions or risks of their loans".

***

  • The complaint says Bishop began working for World in November of 2002 and in 2004 began to observe practices such as World brokers "helping outside brokers to circumvent underwriting guidelines" through classes where "it walked brokers through (World's) loan application and specifically told them to be sure borrowers qualify for loans, even indicating the necessity to overstate income, if need be, to get a borrower qualified."

***

  • The complaint further alleges that "World managers routinely overruled underwriting guidelines that would hae prevented loans from being approved" by using what the filing calls an "exception to policy" to get those loans approved. It says some decisions to deny loans were "overridden" by senior loan originating executives.

For more, see Oakland Bank's Lending Sparks Ex-Employee Lawsuit (read story) (watch video).

For a CBS "60 Minutes" interview with Paul Bishop (aired 2-15-09; 13+ minute video), see World of Trouble (read story) (watch video).

Go here for other posts on whistleblower suits involving alleged fraudulent mortgage lending practices.

Friday, April 06, 2012

BofA Continues Feeding Zombie Debt-Buying Sleaze Factories With Purportedly Unpaid Accounts Backed By Unreliable Records

American Banker reports:
  • Bank of America has sold collections agencies rights to sue over credit card debts that it has privately noted were potentially inaccurate or already repaid.

***

  • At Bank of America, records declared unreliable yet sold to CACH were used to file thousands of lawsuits against consumers, according to a review of hundreds of cases in the state courts where collection suits are typically filed. The overwhelming majority of cases end in default judgments, which are awarded to creditors when borrowers don't show up to contest the claims made against them.


  • In cases where debtors do challenge collections demands in court, the original bank-creditor must testify about the documentation supporting the claims. In several such instances, people identified as Bank of America employees have submitted affidavits attesting to the validity of debts sold by the bank to collections firms.


  • Even though Bank of America previously disavowed "the accuracy of the sums shown as the current balance," the sworn statements vouch for the borrowers' debts down to the penny and declare that the bank's "computerized and hard copy records" back the claims.


  • There are other possible discrepancies, as well: the affidavits state that B of A "has no further interest in this account for any purpose," while the sales contracts reference a "revenue sharing plan."


  • The prospect that B of A was selling unreliable credit card debts did not deter CACH from buying them. A subsidiary of SquareTwo Financial, CACH does not collect debts itself. Instead, it operates like a restaurant franchiser, acquiring rights to the delinquent debts that are the raw materials of the collections business. It then works with law firms around the country that do the actual collections work, providing them with debt files, court witnesses and other services.


  • In thousands of cases in state courts, CACH has appended a single page from its purchase agreements with Bank of America attesting to its ownership of delinquent credit card debt.


  • CACH has omitted from many such filings the more than 30 additional pages where Bank of America disclaims the accuracy of its debt records. Even so, attorneys affiliated with CACH have cited the reliability of Bank of America's records as the foundation for their collections lawsuits.(1)

For more, see Bank of America Sold Card Debts to Collectors Despite Faulty Records.

See Repairing A Broken System: Protecting Consumers in Debt Collection Litigation and Arbitration for a Federal Trade Commission report on dealing with zombie debt.

Go here for other posts on zombie debt.

(1) For related American Banker stories, see:

For more on the problems with zombie debt, see:

Thursday, February 07, 2008

Bank Fires Employee In Retaliation For Blowing Whistle On Mortgage Fraud, Says Lawsuit

In Broward County, Florida, The Miami Herald reports:
  • A former SunTrust Bank mortgage loan coordinator contends in a lawsuit that he was fired after alerting superiors to mortgage fraud occuring at the bank. Some SunTrust loan officers fudged borrowers' incomes and approved multiple loans on investment properties that were actually reported as second homes, ensuring borrowers not only qualified for loans but got them at lower interest rates, said Alan Archambault, a five-year bank employee who was fired late last year. Archambault, 43, of Sunrise, sued SunTrust claiming his firing violated Florida's Whistle Blower Act, which bars companies from taking retaliatory action against employees for objecting to illegal conduct.
For more, see Ex-SunTrust worker challenges firing (A lawsuit accuses SunTrust Bank of firing a mortgage loan coordinator in retaliation for exposing mortgage fraud at the bank).

To view the lawsuit, filed in Broward Circuit Court, see Archambault v. Suntrust Banks Inc., et al.

Go here for other posts on whistleblower suits involving alleged fraudulent mortgage lending practices.