Wednesday, September 02, 2009

Lenders, Mortgage Servicers Flout Local Health & Safety Ordinances When Dealing With Foreclosed Homes, Say Housing Advocates

The Washington Independent reports:
  • As bank-owned foreclosed properties pile up across the country, from abandoned houses in hard-hit neighborhoods to empty big box retail stores in failed strip malls, the fight over holding someone responsible for the brick and mortar mess left behind by the mortgage crisis continues to heat up. More than two years into the crisis, local authorities still are slapping banks, servicers and speculators with fines ranging from $30,000 to even $90,000 for ignoring orders to take care of foreclosed and vacant properties under their control.

***

  • Some of the same servicers the Obama Administration is urging to complete more loan modifications [...] are walking away entirely from vandalized homes, or failing to fix broken windows, get rid of junked cars, clear trash, repair damaged roofs and gutters, or even demolish a condemned house, all of which can be violations of local housing codes. And housing courts keep hearing persistent arguments from servicers that they’re merely temporary custodians who can’t alienate investors by spending money to bring properties up to code.

  • “They may think it’s unfair, but the law provides that if you have ownership of a property, you take care of it,” said Cleveland Housing Court Judge Raymond Pianka,(1) who regularly fines lenders $5,000 a day for properties that don’t comply with city codes. “There’s no provision to exempt corporations. I’m not going to treat them any differently than the individual property owners who come into my courtroom in wheelchairs and walkers.”(2)

***

  • “From my experience, servicing of properties in the inner city, particularly in African-American neighborhoods is either non-existent or erratic,” said Kermit Lind, a Cleveland State University law professor who specializes in housing and foreclosure issues. And, he added, “servicers have testified under oath that they receive instructions to stop maintaining properties and walk away. Servicers have complained that they cannot afford to bring their properties up to code and still make money selling them, and that their investors will not allow them to comply with local laws.” Lind had little sympathy for the plight of servicers, noting archly that “any reasonable person should see that compliance with local building and housing codes protecting the health, safety and welfare of taxpaying neighbors should be subordinated to the duties and responsibilities of servicing and pooling agreements concocted on Wall Street.”

For more, see Lenders, Servicers Fight Anti-Blight and Property Laws (Housing Advocates Say Industry Is Skirting Health and Safety Ordinances, While Taking Taxpayer Money).

(1) Go here for other posts on Judge Pianka's hammering of deadbeat lenders and mortgage servicers in Cleveland Housing Court.

(2) Reportedly, Judge Pianka said some banks and servicers finally are catching on, showing up in his courtroom to answer to violations and repair properties. He’ll often forgive the big fines if a firm cleans up its property. (Court records show Pianka reduced a $30,000 fine for U.S. Bank to $3,000, after the bank brought a house into compliance.) But a recent court docket also gave a glimpse of continuing disputes, from the speculator from Dubai, who bought six properties, sight unseen, off Craigslist, and hasn’t fixed them up, to a real estate company that purchased REO worth only $1,000, and already has racked up $50,000 in fines. BetaVacantForeclosure

Sunday, March 01, 2009

Sloppy Bookkeeping In Securitizations Beginning To Bite Financial Institutions As Big Squeeze On Lenders, Servicers Looms In The Horizon

The New York Times reports:
  • WE are all learning, to our deep distress, how the perpetual pursuit of profits drove so many of the bad decisions that financial institutions made during the mortgage mania. But while investors tally the losses that were generated by loose lending so far, the impact of another lax practice is only beginning to be seen. That is the big banks’ minimalist approach to meeting legal requirements — bookkeeping matters, really — when pooling thousands of loans into securitization trusts.

***

  • THE woes brought on by sloppy bookkeeping in securitizations will be on the agenda at the American Bankruptcy Institute’s annual spring meeting on April 3. An article titled “Where’s the Note, Who’s the Holder,” co-written by Judge [Samuel L.] Bufford and R. Glen Ayers, a former federal bankruptcy judge in Texas, will be the basis of a discussion at the meeting.

  • Mr. Ayers, who is a lawyer at Langley & Banack in San Antonio, said he expects that these documentation problems will halt a lot of foreclosures. That will mean pain for investors who hold the securities. The problem for those who expect to receive the benefit of the note, Mr. Ayers said, is that they “may not be able to show to the judge they have a right to foreclose.” “It’s a huge problem,” he added. “It’s going to be expensive, I don’t know how expensive, ultimately to the bondholders.”(1)

For the story, see Fair Game: Guess What Got Lost in the Loan Pool?

Thanks to Mike Dillon at GetDShirtz.com for the heads-up on the story.

(1) More and more judges, attorneys, and homeowners are taking note of the fact that foreclosing lenders have no business foreclosing on defaulted mortgages unless the lenders (a) produce the promissory note, and more importantly, (b) produce evidence (ie. the chain of title to the note, etc.) that they have the legal right to enforce the note. First in line in feeling the financial squeeze are the loan servicers, according to a recent story in American Banker:

  • [P]ooling and servicing agreements typically require that servicers advance all the principal and interest payments, as well as tax, insurance, maintenance, and foreclosure costs, to investors regardless of whether the borrower is paying. Servicers get reimbursed for expenses incurred while a loan is delinquent but only after the property goes into foreclosure, so getting repaid can take nine months to a year. Large banks with servicing operations may be able to handle the financial strain of paying advances to investors, but independent servicers and special servicers that deal with defaulted borrowers are already cash-strapped, said Matt Stadler, a principal and the chief financial officer at National Asset Direct Inc., a New York buyer and servicer of distressed loans. "Advance lines are ballooning, and servicers are paying interest on those advances," he said. Mr. Stadler likened the state of the servicing industry to the "I Love Lucy" episode in which Lucy is furiously grabbing chocolates off a fast-moving conveyor belt. "The borrowers are just piling up, and servicers are inundated and overwhelmed with calls they can't answer, short sales they can't complete, and not enough staff," he said.

The estimate of nine months to a year that it takes for a servicer to get reimbursed for its advances is obviously based on the foreclosing entity producing the note, and producing satisfactory evidence of its right to enforce it. However, as more and more lenders are unable to produce the proper paperwork in foreclosure actions, these cases are going into indefinite limbo, and will be causing (if they haven't already) a serious financial crush on those loan servicers caught in the middle as they are obligated to continue paying the holders of the securitized interests while the defaulting homeowners continue to properly stiff them. Any payments being made by the homeowners on account of their home mortgage will go directly into a court registry, or their attorney's trust account, pending resolution of the matter. ThetaMissingDocsMtg

Monday, July 13, 2009

Obama Administration About To Turn Up The Heat On Mortgage Servicing Industry Over Sluggishness In Making Loan Modifications?

A column in The New York Times reports on an invitation recently extended(1) by the Treasury & HUD Secretaries to the top 25 mortgage loan servicers to get together in Washington on July 28 for a chat:
  • The subject of the meeting is going to be loan modifications. Specifically, the government is going to be asking — in none-too-friendly fashion — why the nation’s big servicers aren’t doing more to modify loans for homeowners who are in danger of defaulting on their mortgages. Back in the spring, after all, they all signed onto the administration’s new Making Home Affordable program, which uses a series of incentives — not the least of which is $1,000 to the servicers for every mortgage they modify — to help keep people in their homes and prevent foreclosures. And yet, five months later — and two years into the housing bust — the rising tide of foreclosures remains the single biggest threat to economic recovery.

Among the reasons cited by loan servicers for their difficulties in modifying delinquent loans are:

  • The volume of loans is overwhelming servicers,
  • The process is a one-on-one process that requires servicers to actually underwrite the loan, many of which were not properly underwritten when originated (“Servicers have to become full-blown underwriting shops,” according to one loan servicing firm CEO).

However, some suspect the continuing lack of incentive for the lenders and servicers in accomplishing loan modifications as being equally or more compelling reasons for the sluggisness surrounding the loan modification effort:

  • Many times, when a mortgage holder falls behind, he will “self-cure” (as it’s called in the trade) — and eventually get current with his mortgage. So the bank, or the servicer, often has a reason to simply wait him out,

  • The rate of re-default on modified mortgages can be as high as 50 percent, resulting not in foreclosure avoidance, but merely foreclosure postponement,

  • Many institutions also are reluctant to do large-scale mortgage modifications because the write-downs of the portion of the loans they'll have to eat will hurt their balance sheets,

  • The length of time it takes to complete a foreclosure can take a long time, enabling lenders to keep the loans on their books at their inflated values,

  • The $1,000-per-modification being dangled by the government was pretty meaningless, given the amount of time, money and effort they require, according to some in the industry.
For the story, see From Treasury to Banks, an Ultimatum on Mortgage Relief.
.
Thanks to Mike Dillon at GetDShirtz.com for the heads-up on the story.
.
(1) From the story:
  • That letter the administration sent out on Thursday did not mince words. It demanded that the servicers begin “adding more staff than previous planned, expanding call centers beyond their current size, providing an escalation path for borrowers dissatisfied with the service they have received, bolstering training of representatives, developing extra online tools, and sending out additional mailings to borrowers who may be eligible for the program.”

Wednesday, November 02, 2016

More On Statute Of Limitations In Foreclosure Cases

DSNews reports:
  • [T]he expiration of the statute of limitations (SOL) on a servicer’s right to foreclose has long been an issue in New York and Florida. But, it is becoming an increasingly common defense and attack raised by property owners in the Pacific Northwest and Southwest as well.

    Opportunistic investors in states like Arizona are scouring title records looking for loans that have long been in default without the completion of a judicial or non-judicial sale. Borrowers too, in states like Oregon and Washington, are jumping on the bandwagon, claiming that the servicer is prohibited, by its delay, from now foreclosing on the loan. Consequently, servicers must take a close look at their loan portfolio to determine whether the SOL has run or is close to expiring. Most importantly, servicers must know what can be done to stop any further running of the SOL clock.

    For servicers to understand their options, they must first understand what a SOL is and the risk of letting it expire. In the most simplistic terms, a SOL is the outward time limit of when a servicer can enforce its Deed of Trust following a particular default. For example, if the SOL is six years, the servicer must complete its foreclosure within 6 years. If the servicer fails to foreclose within six years, it is arguably prevented from ever foreclosing on its lien, effectively giving the borrower or owner the property free and clear of the Deed of Trust. Needless to say, this is a less than desirable result!

    If the outward limit to foreclose is, say six years, the key question is – what triggers the clock to start running the SOL? Contrary to popular belief, it is not the default itself that starts the clock running; but, rather the existence of a prior notice from the servicer declaring the loan in default and that all sums are immediately due (i.e. acceleration). The problem is that, in many instances, the debt was accelerated long ago (often by a prior servicer as part of a previous foreclosure attempt). In that event, the current servicer could have a ticking time bomb on its hands.

    The SOL defense is generally raised years after a potential acceleration. At that point, servicers (and their legal teams) are left scrambling to review the entire loan file to determine when the first acceleration occurred, whether there were any tolling events preventing the SOL from having already run, and, most importantly, was the loan ever “de-accelerated."

    As we are now several years removed from the height of the financial crisis, the six year SOL on foreclosures in Arizona, Oregon and Washington are becoming an increasingly bigger problem for servicers in these states. Indeed, because servicers may not be aware that acceleration of the loan arguably starts the SOL running, proving that the loan was de-accelerated (or that the running of the statute was tolled) may prove crucial to avoiding the bar to foreclosure.[1]

    This article discusses the applicable SOL period in all three states, what events or actions servicers take that could commence its running, servicers’ ability to waive acceleration and the need to create further precedent confirming this right. ...

Thursday, November 06, 2008

Mortgage Servicers Fearing On Oncoming Foreclosure Moratorium?

An article from American Banker makes the following observation on the trouble mortgage servicing companies may face if a 90-day federal moratorium is imposed on foreclosures:
  • With pressure mounting for Congress to enact a 90-day moratorium on home foreclosures, mortgage servicers are warning that the move could have the perverse effect of prolonging the housing downturn.

***

  • Pooling and servicing agreements typically require that servicers advance all the principal and interest payments, as well as tax, insurance, maintenance, and foreclosure costs, to investors regardless of whether the borrower is paying. Servicers get reimbursed for expenses incurred while a loan is delinquent but only after the property goes into foreclosure, so getting repaid can take nine months to a year.

  • A foreclosure moratorium would indefinitely extend the advances that servicers pay to investors and come as borrowing facilities that servicers rely on to make advance payments are strained by the liquidity crunch.(1)

For more, see Why Foreclosure Relief Worries Many Servicers.

Go here for other related posts on mortgage servicing issues.

(1) According to the story, the chief financial officer of a New York buyer and servicer of distressed loans likened the state of the servicing industry to the "I Love Lucy" episode in which Lucy is furiously grabbing chocolates off a fast-moving conveyor belt. "The borrowers are just piling up, and servicers are inundated and overwhelmed with calls they can't answer, short sales they can't complete, and not enough staff," he said. "They need more manpower." MortgageServicingIssuesAlpha

Thursday, August 12, 2010

New York To Use New Law To Hammer Loan Servicers Giving Financially Strapped Homeowners Loan Modification Jerk-Around

In New York City, ProPublica reports:
  • New York regulators have crafted new laws to give the state authority to punish mortgage servicers -- something the Treasury Department, in administering its struggling mortgage modification program, has so far failed to do. The new rules set clear standards for how servicers must handle homeowners seeking a modification.(1)

  • "We will not hesitate to bring an enforcement action or to refer an enforcement action," said Richard Neiman, the New York superintendent of banks. "In fact, we'll be looking for that case in the event of any wrongdoing, because we know the message it will send to the entire industry."

***

  • The New York laws, which go into effect Oct. 1, lay out how servicers should handle homeowners in danger of foreclosure.(2)

For more, see New York Jumps Ahead of Feds With Law Holding Mortgage Companies Accountable on Mods.

See also, Housing Wire: NY Establishes Loss Mitigation, Fair Dealing Duties for Mortgage Servicers.

(1) See ProPublica: Bankruptcy Judges, Justice Dept. Rip Mortgage Companies for the type of abuses and egregious practices by mortgage servicers that precipitated the need for this new law.

(2) Among other things, the new laws require servicers to have adequate staffing and systems to ensure that homeowners "are not required to submit multiple copies of required documents," a frequent problem, and prohibit servicers from continuing foreclosure proceedings if the homeowner is being evaluated for a modification, the story states. ProPublica has previously reported that foreclosures occurring during the modification process have been a persistent problem.

Sunday, June 26, 2011

Foreclosure Slowdown Leads To Shaky Servicers With Major Cash Flow Squeeze

Housing Wire reports:
  • Mortgage servicers are facing a billion-dollar crisis when it comes to advancing payments and interest to the secondary markets. The problem, according to one panelist providing a mid-year outlook at the American Securitization Forum's annual meeting in Washington, is that mortgage servicers are growing weary of paying for property problems that aren't getting fixed.


  • Heavy foreclosure backlogs and other difficulties in liquidating distressed properties mean mortgage servicers are dealing more and more with negative cash flows in their RMBS portfolios. Mortgage servicers are advancing payments to the secondary markets, even when the properties aren't paying.


  • The assumption is the properties are going to be profitable again, one day. The concern is more and more mortgage servicers doubt this scenerio will actualize. Howard Kaplan, a partner at Deloitte & Touche, said the national average on turning around a distressed property is now more than two years.


  • "If it takes three years to recover, can you imagine the uproar in the markets if servicers stop advancing?" he asked. "Billions and billions of dollars in receivables would stop. This problem will get worse before it gets better."

***

  • Kaplan said secondary market players should appreciate the constraints mortgage servers face. In addition to principal and interest on distressed properties, the servicer still needs to pay local governments, insurance and cover maintenance costs.


  • "I can't emphasis enough the expense on servicers to keep the lawn mowed, the pool clean and pay taxes," he said. "And it's even more complicated if the home is occupied."

Source: Mortgage servicing faces billion-dollar secondary crisis.

Monday, July 01, 2013

BofA Back In The Headlights, Accused Of Deliberate Effort To Dodge Obligations Under Major Lawsuit Settlements While Pocketing Upfront & Periodic Cash By Unloading Loan "Sub"-Servicing Rights To Fly-By-Night, Non-Bank Outfits Not Subject To Bankster-Agreed-To Practices

Freelance writer David Dayen writes in Salon Magazine:
  • Last week, I detailed bombshell revelations from Bank of America whistle-blowers, in which former employees of the bank detailed systematic fraud and deceptive practices inside their loan modification department — including bonuses and Target gift cards for staff who racked up foreclosures.

    Now, another new lawsuit, featuring a separate whistle-blower, contains additional remarkable revelations – and may shed light on Bank of America’s strategy in getting out from under the mountain of legal exposure and costs in which it now finds itself.

    Simply put, the bank seeks to pocket quick cash and evade practices set forth in major settlements – by cashing out of the subprime mortgage servicing business. The result would be to leave struggling homeowners back at square one, with even fewer protections to avoid foreclosure.

    First, some background. Over the past year, non-bank servicers like Nationstar and Ocwen have been buying up servicing rights to millions of mortgages, gradually positioning themselves to become the biggest companies in the space.

    These non-bank servicers, which process monthly payments and deal with foreclosures but do not originate loans, have an asset not available to their big bank colleagues: They haven’t yet been officially caught scamming customers. Therefore, they are not a party to the various servicer settlements brought by state and federal regulators, and they need not submit to those settlement guidelines. This includes rules like establishing a single point of contact for borrowers, stopping foreclosure operations when a modification is in process (ending what is known as “dual track”) and facilitating proper payment processing.

    All of this has come to a head in a class-action lawsuit filed by Leonard Law Office in Massachusetts against Green Tree Servicing, a non-bank servicer based in St. Paul, Minn. As detailed by an insider at Bank of America in a packet of documents, in January 2013, BofA sold servicing rights to 650,000 mortgages (worth $93 billion) to the parent company for Green Tree.

    Like Nationstar and Ocwen, Green Tree is not part of any servicing settlements, nor do they have to abide by any guidelines set by those agreements, even though the loans they purchased were subject to those guidelines when they were in the hands of BofA. Moreover, as a non-bank servicer, Green Tree has traditionally had less stringent oversight from federal regulators, though the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau is fixing to change that.

    Of course, servicers like Green Tree, Nationstar and Ocwen have terrible reputations as among the worst servicers in the country (worse than Bank of America, if you can imagine that). Among the charges Leonard Law Office made against Green Tree were claims that the servicer imposed illegal fees to process any kind of payment; failed to process mailed payments on time; harassed borrowers by calling them at all hours of the night and using abusive language to try to collect on debts; and delayed or denied timely modifications. These practices violate such federal laws as the Fair Debt Collection Practices Act, the Telephone Consumer Protections Act, and others. Complaints about Green Tree’s practices litter theInternet.

    And some complaints have gone to court, like the case of a Florida widow who claimed that Green Tree debt collectors called her husband, as well as his co-workers and relatives, nine times a day about a mortgage debt. Nationstar and Ocwen have seen their share of complaints as well. One innovative Ocwen scam involves sending homeowners a check for $3.50, and claiming that cashing the check automatically enrolls the customer in an appliance insurance plan, which costs $54.95 a month.

    Here’s where Bank of America comes in. According to a bank insider, this is part of a deliberate effort to flip the servicing rights for a quick buck and get out from under the scrutiny of the various settlements. “Brian Moynihan, Ron Sturzenegger and Tony Meola are well aware of the reputations of these servicers,” says the insider, referring to Bank of America’s CEO and two high-level executives. “Ron is a dealmaker, not an operations guy. He was brought in to sell the stuff.”

    Sturzenegger runs Bank of America’s Legacy Asset Servicing Division, $1 trillion or so of the shakiest loans at the bank. By selling off servicing rights, suddenly the bank doesn’t have to comply with settlement practices, nor do they have to increase staff for compliance purposes. So not only do they get some ready cash, they lower their labor costs.

    Sturzenegger worked with Meola, the executive of Fulfillment Operations, to put together the “Bulk Transfer Program,” selling off these mostly delinquent loans to disreputable servicers like Green Tree and Nationstar (the more reputable ones didn’t want any part of them).

    But they only sold the “subservicing” rights. Non-bank servicers like Green Tree service the loans, but Bank of America held onto the so-called master servicing rights. This means that the bank still gets some of the profits from servicing the loans, and none of the responsibility to comply with settlements. Bank of America added a million-plus current loans to the mix of shakier loans to sweeten the pot for the subservicers.

    In the most damning charge, the insider noted that, “It may mean that any modification currently in process with BAC (Bank of America) will not be recognized and the borrower will proceed into foreclosure.” This is almost certainly true, and it’s a very common practice. Servicers who purchase servicing rights are not obligated to follow through on prior agreements with homeowners on loan modifications that have not yet been made permanent. So the homeowner, who thought they were well on their way to saving their home, instead has to start all over with a new servicer.

    Here’s one example from a former Bank of America customer in Puget Sound, Wash., whose switch to Green Tree voided his short sale and put him back in modification hell. Even if the borrower was getting special treatment because of a natural disaster like Hurricane Sandy, that treatment would be voided once the new subservicer entered the picture.

    The Fitch rating agency has recognized the danger of selling off distressed servicing rights to these non-bank operations, saying in a research note that “the growth and outsized scale of larger nonbank servicers may pose challenges to a potential orderly transfer of servicing.” Struggling homeowners will bear the brunt of these challenges.

    Once Charles Giannotti, a friend of Bank of America CEO Brian Moynihan, found out that his servicing transferred to Nationstar, he emailed in a fit of rage. “Are you aware of the fact that your bank is turning its customers over to a processor that based on the complaints posted appears to not only lack basic competency but also poor customer service?” Giannotti fumed. This set off a flood of CYA emails within the bank from senior executives, responding to Moynihan’s queries about the scheme.

    Regardless of how Bank of America resolves this situation, the damage to homeowners has already been done. Homeowners don’t get to choose their servicer – they just get passed around at the whim of big mortgage companies. And every time the servicing rights get transferred, they have to deal with a whole new set of practices. If they were fighting foreclosure at the time of the switch, then they have to start over, under typically disadvantageous circumstances. And that’s especially true when their new servicer sits outside the glare of strict oversight.

    Bank of America’s reputation is already unsalvageable. But avoiding requirements they were forced to make to homeowners to compensate for an initial round of illegal practices, by selling the servicing rights off to fly-by-night organizations that specialize in abusing customers, just about takes the cake. And they’re profiting from it, too.
Source: New Bank of America whistle-blower emerges: More customer abuse secrets (Bank of America whistle-blower details latest scheme to abuse homeowners, evade settlement rules and pocket cash).

Monday, September 13, 2010

Federal Court To Consider Consolidation Of Homeowner HAMP Suits Against BofA Alleging Illegal Jerk-Arounds As Similar Claims Continue To Proliferate

USA Today recently ran a story on the proliferation of lawsuits being brought by financially-strapped homeowners against loan servicers for jerking them around when seeking affordable modifications of their house payments, and points to a recent class action suit brought by Lake Stevens, Washington couple Anthony and April Soper, among others, as an example of these types of suits.
  • Whether the Lake Stevens, Wash., couple keep their home may hinge on the outcome of a legal strategy that aims to join struggling homeowners with similar experiences in the HAMP program in a class-action lawsuit against the nation's largest bank. On Sept. 30 in Nashville, a federal court hearing is scheduled to consider consolidating the Sopers' case with more than a dozen others against Bank of America.

  • Similar lawsuits, also seeking class-action status, are pending against other major servicers such as JPMorgan Chase and Wells Fargo. Taken together, the cases threaten to amplify a growing public frustration with mortgage servicers' treatment of HAMP borrowers and HAMP's modest results.

***

  • Most of the lawsuits allege that the three- or four-month trial payment plans are contracts, and that Bank of America and other servicers broke them by not giving permanent modifications to homeowners who made their trial payments on time and provided the necessary documentation.

  • Servicers have asked courts to dismiss some of the cases, saying the trial plans are not contracts. Bank of America, which says it plans to seek dismissal of the Soper case, argues in a court filing in a similar case that it must consider borrowers for a HAMP modification, but that it has discretion in granting permanent modifications.

***

  • "Borrowers have said we should be able to enforce the contract between Treasury and mortgage servicers, and many courts have rejected that. Our cases are the first filed that touch on a contract between servicers and borrowers," says Kevin Costello, a lawyer with Roddy Klein & Ryan in Boston, which represents homeowners in cases against Bank of America, JPMorgan Chase and Wells Fargo.

  • "This litigation is spreading all across the country. People have been relying on a promise all along, and then they get a denial. Then they find themselves in that much worse of a hole," he says.

***

  • Meanwhile, the number of homeowners claiming improper denials of HAMP modifications is climbing. One is Peter Salinas, 52, who struggled to pay his mortgage after the economy collapsed and his wife developed cancer. He appealed to his lender for help.

  • Salinas says he felt elated last year when he received a HAMP trial modification slashing $500 off his monthly payments. But later, he was told he made too much money to qualify for permanently reduced payments, he says. Wells Fargo threatened foreclosure if he didn't pay $9,000, the difference between his original mortgage and what he paid during the trial.

  • His servicer, Wells Fargo, declined to comment on his situation. Salinas is working with Gulfcoast Legal Services, a not-for-profit [Central Florida] civil legal aid office, that says it is preparing a lawsuit against the lender. "I was convinced I was doing everything right," says Salinas, a reporter for an automotive trade publication who lives near Bradenton, Fla. "I wasn't trying to walk away from this mortgage. It's just infuriating."

For the story, see Home mortgage modification snags spark lawsuits.

Monday, July 27, 2009

Mortgage Servicers To Explain Themselves To Administration Officials Regarding Failure To Keep People In Their Homes

In Washington, D.C., ABC News reports:
  • Mortgage servicers accused of not doing nearly enough to stem the nation's foreclosure crisis will sit down with the Obama administration tomorrow to tell their side of the story.(1) The meeting, the results of which are not expected to be made public until early next month, comes amid escalating criticism that both mortgage servicers and the government are ill-equipped to carry out Obama administration programs designed to help keep people in their homes. [...] The National Consumer Law Center, which presented testimony to the Senate earlier this month, has identified dozens of ways in which some mortgage servicers have failed to follow guidelines set by the Home Affordable Modification Program (HAMP), a five-month-old Obama administration program that pays servicers at least $1,000 for each loan modification.

Reportedly, Sen. Chris Dodd, D-Conn., has asked the administration to investigate alleged abuses of the program by mortgage servicers, which include:

  • Charging advance fees for loan modifications,
  • Telling homeowners they must be in default before becoming eligible for loan modifications,
  • Starting foreclosure proceedings even while a homeowner is under consideration for a loan modification.

For more, see Mortgage Companies to Meet With White House (Meeting Comes Amid Mounting Criticism of Obama Housing Programs).

(1) The mortgage servicers are responding to this recently extended invitation from Treasury Secretary Timothy F. Geithner and HUD Secretary Shaun Donovan to get together for a "friendly chat."

Tuesday, March 11, 2008

Mortgage Servicers Balk At Debt Forgiveness Proposal For Home Mortgages

A Debtwire article appearing in Financial Times reports:
  • Mortgage servicers modifying loans under Hope Now are unlikely to allow principal forgiveness readily, especially when the loans have been securitized, servicers and industry analysts told Debtwire. That may lead to temporary forgiveness through the creation of soft second lien loans, said one industry consultant. In a speech before the Independent Community Bankers of America last week, Federal Reserve Chairman Ben Bernanke encouraged servicers to use principal forgiveness for loss mitigation. He argued that principal writedown makes solid economic sense in some cases, notably when stressed borrowers owe more on their mortgages than their houses are worth.

  • But servicers face strong disincentives to paring down non-performing mortgages because of potential legal exposure should RMBS investors decide they are unwilling to write down principal. What’s more, documents governing the securitization may not allow for such modifications. Even if servicers have the will to forgive debt, they may not have the systems or personnel in place to handle this type of modification.
For more, see Mortgage principal forgiveness will meet resistance from servicers.

Friday, October 23, 2009

Consumer Advocate: Mortgage Servicers Prefer More Profitable Foreclosures To Loan Modifications

From a press release from the National Consumer Law Center:
  • Why have several recent programs designed to encourage loan modifications failed to slow America’s still-worsening home mortgage foreclosure crisis? A new report from the National Consumer Law Center (NCLC) discloses that mortgage servicers – including many large banks – have found it cheaper to foreclose on homeowners than to offer loan modifications that would benefit homeowners and investors.

For the entire press release, see Avoidable Foreclosures Continue Despite Servicers' "Loan Modifications" (New Report Describes How Little Noticed Incentives Prompt Banks to Deny Relief to Homeowners).

Thanks to nationally recognized mortgage servicing fraud watchdog Mike Dillon at GetDShirtz.com for the heads-up on the report.

Go here for Mr. Dillon's commentary on a variety of mortgage servicing fraud issues.

Friday, April 12, 2013

Foreclosure Fraud Settlement Checks To Begin Going Out; Most To Get Paltry Payments

Bloomberg reports:
  • Rust Consulting Inc. will begin sending $125,000 checks to 1,135 borrowers deemed most harmed by botched foreclosures in 2009 and 2010 that led to a $9.3 billion settlement between regulators and U.S. mortgage servicers.

    The consulting firm is distributing $3.6 billion that servicers including JPMorgan Chase & Co. (JPM) and Bank of America Corp. agreed to pay to settle claims they improperly seized homes in the wake of the subprime mortgage crisis, according to a statement from the Office of the Comptroller of the Currency and Federal Reserve.

    Payments will begin to go out April 12, with as many as 90 percent of more than 4 million affected borrowers expected to receive their checks this month, according to the regulators. The agencies expect the process to extend into mid-July, and they are still working on payments to borrowers from servicers that had been affiliated with Goldman Sachs Group Inc. (GS) and Morgan Stanley. (MS)

    Those at the top of the scale for potential harm will receive $125,000, and the 2.6 million categorized at the lowest of 11 rungs of potential harm will get $300, the regulators said. The remainder of the settlement money from the 13 servicers who signed on is meant to be used to prevent future foreclosures.

    After a rash of botched foreclosures during the previous decade’s housing-market collapse, an earlier 2011 settlement called for the servicers to hire outside consultants to review the cases one-by-one and compensate borrowers based on actual harm. After the process was beset by delays, those reviews were mostly scrapped in the current settlement, which is meant to give some level of payment to every borrower who went through foreclosure during the two-year period.

    The Government Accountability Office said in a report released last week that insufficient guidance from the OCC and Federal Reserve slowed down the earlier review process. A Senate subcommittee will examine the relationship between regulators and outside consultants in an April 11 hearing.

Tuesday, October 27, 2009

Mortgage Servicers' Loan Modification Screw-Ups Drive Homeowners To Court Seeking Redress

The Wall Street Journal reports:
  • Some struggling homeowners are turning to the courts in a bid to force mortgage servicers to consider them for the Obama administration's foreclosure-rescue program, arguing they are eligible for help but haven't received it. The suits are the latest sign of difficulties some borrowers are having with the program, which has helped more than 500,000 people begin trial loan modifications since it was announced in February.

  • The program requires mortgage servicers to screen borrowers for eligibility for modifications before completing a foreclosure. But a growing number of borrowers say this isn't happening, or that their requests for help are improperly rejected by the servicers, which collect loan payments and work with delinquent borrowers.

  • "People are unbelievably frustrated with the way [the modification program] is working because it is so nontransparent, and because there is such a basic distrust of servicers," said Ira Rheingold, executive director of the National Association of Consumer Advocates, a group of attorneys and consumer advocates who work with homeowners facing foreclosure.

For more, see Strapped Borrowers Head to Court (Homeowners Press Mortgage Servicers to Rule They Are Eligible for Loan Modifications) (paid Wall Street Journal subscription required; if no subscription, try here, then click link for the story).

(1) Acording to the story, statistics aren't available, but attorneys say legal action tied to the rescue program is being taken in states including California, Florida, Ohio and Pennsylvania. A lawsuit seeking class-action status in U.S. District Court in Minnesota (go here for press release) wants to halt foreclosures on homeowners eligible for the rescue program until the administration puts in place certain procedural safeguards, such as creating a formal appeals process, the story states [see Advocacy Group Files Federal Suit Seeking To Halt Home Foreclosures In Minnesota; Says New Law Lacks Proper Notice & Appeal Provisions]. South Carolina Supreme Court Chief Justice Jean Toal in May reportedly issued an order requiring that all complaints seeking foreclosure state whether the loan is subject to the rescue program and, if so, why the borrower doesn't have a loan modification.

Sunday, February 28, 2010

Loan Servicers Feel The Squeeze From Increased Denials Of Mortgage Insurance Claims

Housing Wire reports:
  • In the face of dwindling business, with January 2010 showing fewer new policies than any month in 2009, mortgage insurance (MI) companies are increasingly denying claims for defaulted loans that allegedly do not conform to underwriting standards, increasing costs for servicers and investors.

  • Historically, mortgage insurance (MI) rescission rates were low, generally around 7%, but in recent quarters, that rate has jumped to 25%, associate analyst Aleksandra Simanovsky wrote in the Moody’s Investors Service latest “ResiLandscape” commentary provided to HousingWire.

  • According to Moody’s, the issue came to a head in December 2009, when Bank of America [] filed a lawsuit against MGIC [], claiming the insurer improperly denied claims from BofA’s servicer unit. While the lawsuit is still pending, mortgage insurers are becoming more confident in denying partial or whole claims from servicers and Simanovsky wrote the industry can expect continued high rescission rates for the future.

***

  • MI companies are taking a harder look at expenses for property preservation and utility bills and many times, servicers’ claims are denied because the MI companies claim the expenses are not “reasonable and customary.” In addition, servicers are receiving reduced reimbursements on tax and insurance advances that result from extended holding times. "As unsold home inventories continue to build and as foreclosure and REO timelines grow longer, losses to securitized trusts are expected to increase to the extent that MI companies are not covering such expenses,” Simanovsky wrote.

For more, see Growing Trend of Mortgage Insurance Claim Denials are Costing Servicers.

Thursday, July 30, 2009

Lenders, Mortgage Servicers Continue To Force Borrowers To Waive Legal Rights As Part Of Loan Modification Process

The Washington Independent reports:
  • Even as the Obama administration presses the lending industry to get more mortgage loans modified, the practice of forcing borrowers to sign away their legal rights in order to get their loans reworked is a tactic that some servicers just won’t give up on. Waivers requiring borrowers to give up any legal claims related to their mortgages, even in cases where borrowers may be victims of predatory lending, are showing up sporadically in loan modification agreements under the Obama administration’s Making Home Affordable plan, consumer attorneys say. They were stunned to find the legal waivers still being used, despite more than a year of efforts – including calls from lawmakers – to get rid of them.

  • “It was shocking to see that people are still being asked to waive their legal rights,” said Bruce Dorpalen, national director of housing counseling for ACORN Housing Corp. “I mean, this should be abolished. It’s incredible that it’s still in there.” [...] The Treasury Department’s published guidelines for the $75 billion taxpayer funded program specifically prohibit the waivers. Mortgage giants Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac removed the waivers from their standard loan modification agreements earlier this year. But Diane Thompson, an attorney with the National Consumer Law Center, said she has seen legal waivers resurface in loan modification agreements by Aurora Loan Services, Ocwen Financial Corp., and other firms. She also is getting complaints about waivers in Bank of America agreements. “The waivers continue to be an issue,” Thompson said.(1)

For more, see Loan Servicers Work the Fine Print in Obama Foreclosure Plan (A Year After Calls for Reform, Borrowers Still Forced to Waive Legal Rights for Loan Modifications).

(1) It may be time for the Obama administration to stop throwing money at the lenders and servicers for loan modification programs and redirect the cash towards establishing and supporting foreclosure defense programs for financially strapped homeowners the way Florida Attorney General Bill McCollum recently did. See Attorney General Launches Multi-Million Dollar Grant Program for Foreclosure Defense Assistance (The Florida Bar Foundation will help administer $4 million in grants to legal services applicants).

The thought of having to deal with "producing the notes," and otherwise establishing proper legal standing to initiate foreclosures, as well as addressing allegations of fraud and violations of the applicable consumer protection laws is sure to get the attention of the mortgage industry, in my view. After all, why else are the loan servicers so intent on getting homeowners to waive their legal rights?

Friday, August 01, 2008

Freddie To Double Cash Incentives To Servicers Working With Delinquent Borrowers

Reuters reports:
  • [F]reddie Mac, a government-chartered company, will [...] increase the time it gives servicers to negotiate with delinquent borrowers in Washington, D.C., and 20 states to 300 days from a range of 120 to 299 days, a spokeswoman said. The states are those with relatively fast foreclosure processes, Freddie Mac said.

***

  • Compensation to servicers that negotiate new payment plans and loan contracts will double to $500 and $800, respectively, Freddie Mac said. For a servicer that completes a so-called short-sale, in which Freddie Mac accepts a sale price on a home below the balance of the mortgage, payments also double, to $2,200. Accepting short sales can result in lower losses for lenders by ending the delinquency period and preventing ownership of the property through foreclosure.

  • Among new incentives, Freddie Mac said it will reimburse servicers for the cost of door-to-door programs -- in which servicers seek out troubled borrowers in person to discuss renegotiating their loans -- if they result in the borrower contacting the servicer.

For more, see Freddie Mac boosts mortgage servicer incentives.

Tuesday, April 08, 2008

Ohio Governor, Mortgage Servicing Companies Engage In Publicity Stunt Affecting Homeowners In Foreclosure

In Columbus, Ohio, Bloomberg News reports:

  • Citigroup Inc., HSBC Finance Corp., and seven other mortgage companies agreed to help delinquent Ohio borrowers avoid foreclosure in the first such accord between a state and home-loan servicers, Ohio Governor Ted Strickland said. [...] The companies signed non-binding compacts agreeing to notify borrowers four to six months before their adjustable-rate mortgages reset, said Kimberly Zurz, director of Ohio's Department of Commerce. Seven agreed to lock in adjustable rates for qualified borrowers for as long as five years, she said.

***

  • The other companies that signed agreements were GMAC RESCAP/Homecomings Financial, Carrington Mortgage Services, Ocwen Financial Corp., Option One Mortgage, Saxon Mortgage Services, Select Portfolio Servicing and Litton Loan Servicing, Strickland said in a statement.

For the rest of the story, see Citigroup, HSBC, 7 Others to Assist Ohio Homeowners.

Editorial Note:

It's hard not to believe that the loan servicers who agreed to this non-binding agreement (which, in law, is no agreement at all) are simply giving lip service to take the heat off them in Ohio. Given the facts that:

  • Ohio recently announced that qualified homeowners in foreclosure may have free legal representation available to them,

  • the same announcement informs us that Ohio foreclosure defense training for attorneys representing homeowners in the state has reportedly been made available through the Ohio Bar Association,

  • it is no secret that foreclosing mortgage holders and servicers are having a tough time finding and filing the proper documentation in court proving their right to bring foreclosure actions,

  • a recent media report informs us that an Ohio appeals court ruled last month that a foreclosing mortgage company is not entitled to a foreclosure judgment if they can't prove their ownership of the promissory note and how they came about owning the mortgage (see Everhome Mtge. Co. v. Rowland, 2008-Ohio-1282; (10th Dist. Ct. App.; March 20, 2008)), and

  • other Ohio appellate court decisions also seem to point to the apparent need for a foreclosing mortgage lender to prove that it is the owner of the promissory note and, thererfore, the real party in interest to initiate the legal action (see First Union Natl. Bank v. Hufford (2001), 146 Ohio App.3d 673; 3rd Dist. Ct. App. ; and Washington Mut. Bank, F.A. v. Green (2004), 156 Ohio App.3d 461; 7th Dist. Ct. App.),

the loan servicers are obviously feeling enough pressure to participate with the Ohio governor in this publicity stunt. Everyone appears to come away looking good, but it seems to me that unless the loan servicers can physically produce the promissory note, and prove that there were no violations of the Federal Truth In Lending Act ("TILA", as well as any applicable state consumer protection law) when the loan was originated, the homeowners really have little incentive to agree to a loan workout (unless, of course, the terms of any such loan workout are highly favorable to the homeowners and reflect the fact that promissory notes are missing and "TILA" violations were committed).

Now that there are attorneys involved who are representing homeowners, it appears to me that those attorneys have now taken up the obligation to assure their clients/homeowners that all the laws affecting their mortgage loans and all the rules governing the legal procedure in foreclosure cases have been complied with. I expect that these attorneys will not let the mortgage companies off the hook on their obligations, unless of course, they are prepared to make significant concessions to the homeowners when ironing out a loan modification.

---------------------

For more on mortgage companies' obligations in foreclosure actions, see Fight Foreclosure: Make ‘Em Produce The Note!.

For other posts that reference the failure of some mortgage lenders and their attorneys to file the required loan documents when starting foreclosures, Go Here, Go Here, Go Here, and Go Here.

For other posts on homeowners using Federal & state consumer protection statutes to try and undo bad mortgage loans, Go Here, Go Here, and Go Here. undo mortgage loans TILA batallion missing mortgage foreclosure docs beta

Friday, January 30, 2009

Impediments To Voluntary Loan Modifications

Contained in a recent report(1) issued by the Center For Responsible Lending (CRL) is a list of existing barriers that impede the effectiveness of voluntary mortgage loan modifications between loan servicers and financially strapped homeowners seeking relief from unaffordable house payments:
  1. Mortgage securitization: When servicing securitized loans, servicers are bound by the terms of contracts that may impose legal limitations on modifying loans that are included in investment pools;
  2. Fear of lawsuits: Another legal impediment is fear of investor lawsuits, since most loan modifications will have disparate financial impacts on different classes of investors in any given security;
  3. Financial incentives to foreclose: The way that servicers are compensated by lenders often creates a bias for foreclosing on a mortgage rather than trying to prevent foreclosure. Servicer costs are reimbursed following a foreclosure, but generally not reimbursed for a modification in privately securitized mortgages;
  4. Second mortgages: Between one-third and one-half of the homes purchased in 2006 with subprime mortgages were made with two mortgages, and many more homeowners have open home equity lines of credit secured by their home;
  5. Obstacles to assistance by servicers: Despite repeated attempts and many hours of effort, many homeowners report they repeatedly get put on hold when they call servicers or bounced from one person to another without receiving any meaningful assistance.

For a more detailed discussion of these obstacles to modifying mortgages, see testimony before the Senate Banking Committee presented by Eric Stein, Senior Vice President of the Center for Responsible Lending.

For the CRL (January 2009) report itself, see Continued Decay and Shaky Repairs (The State of Subprime Loans Today).

(1) The report provides an update on the subprime mortgages that triggered the current foreclosure crisis, focusing on the performance of these loans and efforts to stop the ongoing surge of foreclosures.

Wednesday, September 03, 2008

Freddie Reminds Servicers To Cut Some Slack To Gustav Victims

In McLean, Virginia, Freddie Mac announces:
  • Freddie Mac today reminded its servicers of the disaster relief options available to borrowers with Freddie Mac-owned mortgages who were affected by Hurricane Gustav. [...] Servicers can offer relief under Freddie Mac guidelines to borrowers whose homes were damaged or destroyed, as well as borrowers who may be unable to make their mortgage payments because they were evacuated to avoid the storm. Servicers should assess each case individually to determine if relief is warranted and which option best fits the homeowner's circumstances.

  • In addition, Freddie Mac gives servicers the discretion to reduce or suspend mortgage payments or foreclosure proceedings for up to 12 months for borrowers with Freddie Mac-owned mortgages in federally declared major-disaster areas where individual assistance was provided.

For more, see Freddie Mac Extends Mortgage Relief To Borrowers Affected By Hurricane Gustav.