Monday, March 19, 2007

New Jersey AG, Consumer Affairs Director Warn Against Foreclosure Rescue Scams Involving "Surplus Funds"

New Jersey Attorney General Stuart Rabner and Acting Consumer Affairs Director Stephen B. Nolan recently issued a warning to New Jersey residents about a foreclosure rescue scam involving "surplus funds", the money that represents that portion of the sale proceeds of a foreclosure sale that is left over after the proceeds are first applied to paying off the amount owed to a foreclosing mortgage lender and, (apparently) in New Jersey, any unpaid real estate taxes, according to a Press Release from the New Jersey AG's office.

These surplus funds, also referred to as the "surplus money", "excess funds" or "overage" (and possibly other terms), represent the homeowner's equity in his/her home that they are entitled to claim after the foreclosure sale takes place. Therefore, and contrary to what some foreclosure rescue operators will falsely have people believe, when a homeowner loses his/her home in a foreclosure sale, the home equity, if any, is not necessarily lost. If the sale price exceeds the amount owed, the balance (ie. the surplus funds) is typically held in an account by the court that ordered the sale and it simply sits there until the homeowner comes forward and claims it (or until a scam artist comes forward, forges or otherwise tricks the homeowner into signing the necessary paperwork, and steals it - see, for example, Arrests Made in South Florida Foreclosure Scams, involving an alleged theft of foreclosure surplus funds that may have victimized at least 20 Florida homeowners).

Further, because of the significant increase in third party investors attending and bidding at these foreclosure sales throughout the U.S. over the last few years (in large part due to the spike in property values in many parts of the country during the early 2000's; in some part due to the "foreclosure investing" infomercials on late night cable TV), the sale prices at these foreclosure sales have typically come pretty close to full fair market value (unlike the old days when an investor could pick up a pretty good deal at a significant discount at these forced sales). As a result, it has been quite common for there to be surplus funds left over after a foreclosure sale took place and a foreclosing lender got paid off on its outstanding loan.

Due to the fact that many homeowners are unaware of their rights to the surplus money, a profit opportunity is open for both the ethical and the unethical to capitalize on the recovery of these surplus funds. This is the case in spite of the fact that, at least in New Jersey, homeowners can obtain the surplus funds on their own simply by filing a simple form and paying less than $100 (if you're a New Jersey resident, more information is available from the New Jersey Superior Court Trust Fund Unit at 609-292-3937; my guess is that other local court systems throughout the rest of the U.S. have some type of system for assisting homeowners recover their surplus funds).

The unethical and the con artists who have gotten into this area of foreclosure rescue have engaged in one of two forms of this scam (which can be thought of as a creative form of "equity stripping") and which are described in the Press Release. To read more, see Consumers Cautioned About “Surplus Funds” Scams Amid Rising Foreclosure Filings.

For concise, one page brochures warning against scams involving the surplus money left after a foreclosure sale, see:

To read about the recent legal action settled by the Washington State Attorney General against three foreclosure rescue operators involving a "surplus funds" scam, see More On AG McKenna's Settlement With Foreclosure Rescue Operators.

Click here to Watch the TV report on the Washington case on Channel 4 KOMO-TV

Editor's Note:

I suspect that, because of the general downturn in values in the real estate market recently, more and more lenders will be foreclosing on homes on which they're owed more than what the properties are worth; these properties are said to be "upside down". In these cases, the foreclosing mortgage lenders will be stuck buying these "upside down" properties themselves at a foreclosure auction or forced into allowing the properties to be sold to third party bidders at said auction for less than the amount owed. Accordingly, in these cases there will be no surplus funds for homeowners to claim.
(corrected 3-22-07)
.

Thursday, November 12, 2009

NYC Man Accused Of Using Forged Documents In Attempt To Swipe $128K From Foreclosed Homeowner In Alleged "Surplus Scam"

From the Office of the Queens County District Attorney:
  • Queens District Attorney Richard A. Brown [...] announced that a Flushing man has been charged with second-degree attempted grand larceny, second-degree criminal possession of a forged instrument and other charges for allegedly forging the signature of a man whose home had been foreclosed on in an effort to collect the surplus that resulted from a sale of the house.(1) District Attorney Brown said, “The defendant is accused of trying to steal a large amount of money owed to the victim in this case – and then challenging the victim in court when the scheme was uncovered. [...].”

***

  • District Attorney Brown said that, according to the charges, the complainant, Leonard Lum, was the owner of a property [...] in Corona, Queens, which was foreclosed upon on March 21, 2003. As a result of the foreclosure, there was a surplus of $128,044 owed to him as proceeds from the sale of his property through foreclosure action. The District Attorney said that, on December 17, 2008, the complainant filed an action [...] to collect the surplus.(2)

  • On February 9, 2009, however, the defendant Harry Coumnas, of H.C. Sonic, Inc., allegedly filed a petition with the court in opposition of the complainant’s action, claiming that the complainant had assigned rights to the defendant to collect the $128,044 surplus in exchange for a payment of $25,000. The District Attorney further said that the defendant allegedly hired an attorney to file papers in an effort to collect the surplus, which included filing documents bearing the forged signatures of Leonard Lum and his wife, Betty Lum, purportedly assigning the surplus of $128,044 to the defendant in exchange for $25,000. According to the criminal complaint, the complainant never assigned the right to the surplus to the defendant and did not receive the sum of $25,000 from the defendant.

For the entire Queens DA press release, see Flushing Man Charged With Filing Fraudulent Court Papers To Collect Foreclosure Surplus (Allegedly Forged Victim’s Signature In Bid To Collect $128,000).

(1) The District Attorney identified the defendant as Harry Coumnas, 50, of 25-25 126th Street in Flushing. The defendant is charged with second-degree attempted grand larceny, second-degree criminal possession of a forged instrument, first-degree falsifying business records and first-degree offering a false instrument for filing.

(2) Assuming the absence of typographical errors in the DA's press release, it appears that the $128K foreclosure surplus was sitting in the court registry for well over five years before the foreclosed homeowner "woke up" and attempted to retrieve his funds (March 21, 2003 to December 17, 2008). For all anyone knows, he (like most people who lose their homes to foreclosure) may not have been aware that he's entitled to money from the foreclosure sale of his home to the extent the sale price exceeds the debt owed to the foreclosing lender (subject to the claims of any intervening lienholders), and may only have become aware of his right to the cash after having his suspicions aroused by one of the many "foreclosure surplus chasers" who make their living ripping off foreclosed homeowners unaware of their rights to the sale overage.

Monday, August 15, 2011

Judge Slams S. Jersey Foreclosure Surplus Snatcher For $675K+ In Ex-Homeowner Ripoff; State AG Vows To Grab Scammer's Assets To Satisfy Court Judgment

From the Office of the New Jersey Attorney General:
  • A Superior Court Judge has determined that a Camden County businessman committed multiple violations of the state’s Consumer Fraud Act (“CFA”) when he misled homeowners in foreclosure into believing that they needed his help in obtaining surplus funds to which they were legally entitled.(1)

***

  • Filed in Gloucester County, the State’s two-count civil complaint alleged that Samuel E. Goodwin, III, 75, of Gloucester City, charged homeowners up to 65% of the total surplus funds remaining once the foreclosure process was completed. In June 2010, the State filed a Motion for Summary Judgment, which the court granted in part, finding that Goodwin violated the CFA by misrepresenting to consumers that surplus funds could be lost to the State. In March 2011, the State renewed its Motion for Summary Judgment.


  • In its Final Judgment and Order, the court granted the State’s renewed Motion for Summary Judgment:

    Finding that Goodwin engaged in unconscionable commercial practices in violation of the CFA by imposing fees ranging from approximately $5,300 to $56,540 for applying for surplus funds on behalf of consumers;

    Permanently enjoining Goodwin from advertising and otherwise soliciting consumers to submit surplus fund applications;

    Permanently enjoining Goodwin from retaining an attorney to file surplus fund applications on behalf of consumers; and

    Permanently enjoining Goodwin from receiving any monetary payment derived from any application for release of surplus funds
    .


  • “Goodwin took advantage of homeowners going through foreclosure, and attempted to enrich himself, by misleading consumers in order to charge outrageous fees,” Attorney General Paula T. Dow said. “We remain vigilant, and are ready to take action, against anyone who attempts to take advantage of homeowners facing foreclosure.”


  • In addition to paying $329,198.08 in restitution to 24 consumers, the court also ordered Goodwin to pay $225,000 in civil penalties to the State, plus $122,998 in reimbursement for the State’s attorneys’ fees and investigative costs.


  • The Final Judgment and Order has been entered as a statewide lien. The Division of Consumer Affairs will continue its efforts to identify any assets that Goodwin may have now, and in the future, to be applied to satisfy the Final Judgment and Order.


  • “This defendant stole from the desperate and vulnerable – people suffering from the anguish of losing their homes,” said Thomas R. Calcagni, Director of the State Division of Consumer Affairs. “Our Financial Fraud Unit continues its fight to protect distressed homeowners from financial predation, and we intend to pursue Goodwin and his assets, so restitution is paid to those who were deceived.”

For the NJ AG press release, see Camden County Businessman Ordered to Repay $329,000 to Consumers Whose Homes Were Foreclosed Upon and Sold, Under Settlement with the New Jersey Division of Consumer Affairs.

Go here for Statewide Judgement and Lien.

(1) Surplus funds are the monies remaining after the foreclosure sale takes place and mortgage, tax, and other legal obligations have been paid. In August 2007, when the State Division of Consumer Affairs filed its lawsuit, homeowners in foreclosure could claim surplus funds by filing a simple form available from the Superior Court Trust Fund Unit and after paying nominal fees totaling less than $100. The process for obtaining surplus funds has since changed and the current process provides for a motion for release of surplus funds to be filed by the party named in the judgment of foreclosure with the Office of Foreclosure.

Sunday, October 04, 2009

NJ Attorney Dodges Serious Sanctions In Improper Fee-Splitting Deal w/ Foreclosure Surplus "Snatcher"; Lawyer "Not Venal" - Just Clueless, Says DRB

In Trenton, New Jersey, the New Jersey Law Journal reports:
  • The New Jersey Supreme Court has censured a Point Pleasant, N.J., solo for splitting fees with a company that helped him find clients entitled to surplus funds from sheriff's foreclosure sales.(1) The court adopted the Disciplinary Review Board's finding that Garrett Lardiere's business relationship with Vermont-based Equinox Research and Recovery Co. constituted impermissible sharing of legal fees with non-lawyers.

  • According to the DRB, Lardiere's relationship with Equinox dates to 2003. The company researches foreclosure records to find surplus funds from sheriff's sales on deposit in New Jersey Superior Court. Equinox sent letters printed on Lardiere's letterhead to individuals it believed were entitled to such funds. The letters were signed by an Equinox employee and listed the company's toll-free phone number.

***

  • The DRB, in a July 23 opinion, said the record included letters from Equinox to Lardiere that "call into question respondents' professional independence" in the matters in question. In one, Lardiere was urged to refer inquiries from would-be clients to Equinox, because "we know what is going on in the case and stand a better chance in getting them to sign at a higher rate," a company representative wrote.(2)

  • Lardiere "relinquished control of his cases to an organization of non-lawyers who were acting under color of his name in dealing with his clients," the DRB found. In addition, he failed to ensure that his clients' interests would be protected.(3)

***

  • The DRB said either a censure or a three-month suspension could be supported for the fee-sharing offense, combined with the record-keeping and failure to cooperate offenses. It imposed censure based on Lardiere's 35-year unblemished record. "Respondent is not venal. Rather, he has a distinct lack of knowledge or a lack of understanding about his responsibilities as a member of the bar," the DRB said.

For more, see Attorney Censured for Splitting Fees With Foreclosure-Research Company.

For information on how foreclosed New Jersey homeowners can claim any surplus funds on their own, see:

Go here for other stories on "foreclosure surplus" scams.

(1) When the sales price of a home sold at a foreclosure or sheriff's sale exceeds what is owed to the mortgage holder, the excess is generally referred to as the "foreclosure surplus," "surplus funds," or "the overage."

(2) Reportedly, people who responded to the solicitations were asked to sign a contingency agreement with Lardiere, which came attached to the letter. But the letters contained none of the language required in attorney-solicitation letters under New Jersey Rule of Professional Conduct 7.3, such as a prominent heading with the word "Advertisement" or a notice that the recipient may contact the Committee on Attorney Advertising if the content is misleading or inaccurate, the DRB said.

With respect to the compensation scheme. Equinox received a percentage of the funds recovered, and Lardiere received a cut of Equinox's share, along with a flat fee of $750 per case. When Lardiere received a recovery, he deposited it in his trust account and disbursed the proceeds to the client, to Equinox and to himself.

(3) The DRB also found Lardiere's violated record-keeping strictures by keeping unreconciled trust accounts, and further that he was reluctant to give ethics investigators unfettered access to his files, constituting a failure to cooperate with disciplinary authorities. lawyer renting UnauthPractOfLawTheta

Monday, August 01, 2016

Indiana Appeals Court: Surplus Proceeds From 2nd Mortgage Foreclosure Sale Belongs To Homeowner, Not 1st Mortgage Holder; Sneaky Bankster Almost Gets Away With Illegally Snatching Away Excess Sale Proceeds By Duping Empty-Headed Trial Judge To Award It The Cash

In Bloomington, Indiana, The Indiana Lawyer reports:
  • A trial court misapplied the law regarding disbursement of surplus sale proceedings from a sheriff’s sale when it ordered the full surplus to the bank that owned the first mortgage on the home, the Indiana Court of Appeals held. The law requires the surplus to go to the mortgage debtor.

    John and Manee Edler had two mortgages through Regions Bank on their Bloomington home, the first mortgage was on the property; the second mortgage was related to a home equity line of $30,000.

    In June 2013, Regions Bank alleged the Edlers were in default on the second mortgage only, with a balance of $22,933.56. The complaint did not allege any default regarding the first mortgage. In a foreclosure decree, the judge stated the second mortgage is superior to all other liens and claims, except the first mortgage.(1) The decree ordered the home sold in a sheriff’s sale, which David Jenner bought for $82,600.(2)

    Regions petitioned for a portion of that amount to cover the second mortgage and then the rest of the surplus to be applied to the first mortgage. The court granted the full $82,600 to Regions. The Edlers filed a motion to correct, which was denied, seeking the surplus. John Edler passed away while this appeal was pending.(3)

    Judge Michael Barnes turned to Indiana Code 32-30-10-14, which governs mortgage foreclosure sales and surplus sales proceeds. This statute requires surplus directed to the “mortgage debtor, mortgage debtor’s heirs, or other persons assigned by the mortgage debtor.” The COA also cited two cases from the 19th century to support its reversal.

    “This case is slightly unusual in that Regions obviously had notice of the foreclosure action on the second mortgage but chose to make no effort to foreclose on the first mortgage or otherwise have its rights adjudicated with respect to the first mortgage. Having chosen this course of action, Regions could not essentially reverse course by seeking the surplus sales proceeds, in clear contravention of the foreclosure statutes and relevant case law,” Barnes wrote.

    He also noted how Regions now decides to collect the debt associated with first mortgage is beyond the scope of this opinion.(4)

    Manee Edler v. Regions Bank, and Jenner Properties, LLC, 53A01-1512-MF-2264, is remanded with instructions to distribute the surplus sale proceeds to Manee Edler.
Source: COA: Woman, not bank, entitled to foreclosure surplus funds.

For the court ruling, see Edler v. Regions Bank, 53A01-1512-MF-2264 (Ind. App. July 21, 2016).
--------------------
(1) The outstanding balance on the first mortgage was approximately $60,000, per the court ruling.

(2) According to the court ruling, Jenner then "invested approximately $100,000.00 in renovating the property and reached an agreement to sell it to a third party for $199,000.00."

(3) The Edlers had fallen behind on both mortgage payments after Mr. Edler developed cancer, per the court ruling.

(4) In footnote 5 of the ruling, the court also noted that it offers no opinion as to the effect of its holding on Regions’s agreement with Jenner to release the first mortgage, or the pending sale of the property by Jenner to a third party.

Wednesday, October 28, 2015

NJ AG Reaches Settlement w/ Four Real Estate Operators Resolving Allegations Of Deception, Misrepresentations Made In Targeting Ex-Homeowners For Foreclosure Sale "Surplus Funds" Ripoffs

From the Office of the New Jersey Attorney General:
  • Three companies and one individual that advertised, offered for sale and sold services to locate “surplus funds” or other property owed to consumers have entered into settlements with the New Jersey Division of Consumer Affairs.

    According to the terms of the settlements, the Division of Consumer Affairs identified violations of the Consumer Fraud Act and/or the Advertising Regulations arising from the advertisement, offering for sale and/or sale of services to locate, deliver, recover or assist in the recovery of property by the following:

    U.S. Financial Funding LLC and Jeffrey Richman, of Charlotte, North Carolina;

    Capital Recovery III, LLC, Capital Recovery Inc. II, Charles Demes and Alan Dumond of Chicago, Illinois;

    Jose A. Danoys d/b/a “JD Assets Recovery” of Old Bridge, New Jersey; and

    Hunterdon Legal Service LLC, d/b/a “Superior Court Services,” and Steven C. Searfoss, d/b/a “Steven C. Thomas,” of Flemington, New Jersey.

    Under the terms of the settlements, these businesses were collectively assessed $309,673.33 in civil penalties, disgorgement to consumers, and reimbursement of attorneys’ fees and costs.

    “Surplus funds” are funds remaining after a property foreclosure sale and all payments ordered by the Court have been made, which can often total in the thousands of dollars. The homeowner is entitled to apply for these funds if they exist.

    “These settlements resolve allegations that these businesses falsely represented that consumers needed their assistance to obtain surplus funds from foreclosure sales. Homeowners who have lost their homes in foreclosure should be aware that they do not need to pay a business in order to apply for money they are rightfully entitled to,” Acting Attorney General John J. Hoffman said.

    “Some businesses allegedly convinced consumers to pay thousands of dollars for unnecessary help obtaining ‘surplus funds’ by making misrepresentations and creating confusion,” said Steve Lee, Acting Director of the Division of Consumer Affairs. “Consumers should be aware of such illegal practices whenever they are going through a foreclosure.”

    As to U.S Financial Funding, the alleged violations included misrepresenting that surplus funds and other property would be lost to the government if not recovered quickly; using contracts that failed to set forth the consumer’s share of the surplus funds; and charging fees that were more than 35% of the value of the property recovered. In the settlement, U.S. Financial Funding was assessed $71,250.77, of which $66,250.77 is suspended and will become vacated if it follows the terms of its settlement with the Division for the next three years. As part of the settlement, U.S. Financial Funding also agreed to discontinue doing business in New Jersey.

    As to Capital Recovery, the alleged violations included failing to identify the property to be recovered in its solicitation letters; using contracts that failed to set forth the consumer’s share of the surplus funds; and charging fees for the recovery of property that were excessive or unjust. In the settlement, Capital Recovery was assessed $97,197.30, of which $40,000 is suspended and will become vacated if the terms of the settlement with the Division are successfully met for the next three years.

    As to JD Assets Recovery, the alleged violations included using a solicitation letter which misrepresented that “time is of the essence” and that after a period of time the property would be permanently lost; and using contracts that failed to set forth the consumer’s share of the surplus funds after deduction of its recovery. In the settlement, JD Assets Recovery was assessed $36,000, of which $30,000 is suspended and will become vacated if the terms of its settlement with the Division are successfully met for the next three years.

    As to Hunterdon Legal Service, the alleged violations included using the term “Superior Court Services” in its solicitation letters and contracts, thus suggesting an affiliation with the Superior Court, which was not the case; misrepresenting that it was entitled to a fixed percentage of any property to be recovered; and charging fees for recovery of property that were excessive or unjust. In the settlement, Hunterdon Legal Service was assessed $105,225.26, of which $40,000 is suspended and will become vacated if terms of its settlement with the Division are successfully met for the next three years.

    Homeowners can apply for surplus funds themselves, by contacting the Trust Fund Unit of the State Superior Court at (609) 292-4012. To learn more about surplus funds, please see the Division of Consumer Affairs’ Consumer Brief online.

Wednesday, December 10, 2008

Central Florida Lawyer Gets 15 Years Probation For Stealing Foreclosure Surplus Funds From Clients

In Orlando, Florida, WFTV Channel 9 reports:
  • An Orange County lawyer can no longer practice law and is on probation for 15 years after taking advantage of foreclosure clients. Investigators said Norman Sanders Moss took advantage of the foreclosure crisis and kept money from auctions of foreclosed homes.(1) Moss pleaded guilty to grand theft and offered one of his victims an apology.

***

  • Moss was ordered to work 40 hours a week in order to pay the victim, Nicholas Cabrera, back the $31,000 he stole from him. However, the former attorney will have to obtain a job that doesn't allow him to handle money or practice law.

Source: Lawyer Apologizes For Stealing Victim's Money.

(1) This money, commonly referred to as Foreclosure Surplus Funds, are proceeds generated from the sale of a home at a foreclosure, trustee's, or sheriff ’s sale over and above the balance owed on the foreclosing mortgage. Where a foreclsoure sale yields such a surplus, the foreclosed homeowner may be entitled to the money, provided there aren't any secondary liens on the foreclosed property, in which case these lien holders could have priority in their claims to the surplus. In some cases, this surplus could total thousands of dollars, although in the current real estate market, the vast majority of foreclosure sales are not attracting third party bidders, are being acquired by the foreclosing lenders, and consequently, are not yielding surpluses.

Monday, March 15, 2010

New Washington State Law Targets Foreclosure "Surplus-Snatching" Scams; Caps "Overage-Chaser/Scavenger" Fees At 5% In Tax Sales

In Olympia, Washington, LegalNewsline reports:
  • Washington residents who lose their home because of back property taxes could get a little extra money in the end thanks to a bill championed by state Attorney General Rob McKenna that was signed into law Friday. Signed by Democratic Gov. Chris Gregoire, the new law places a 5 percent cap on fees charged by firms that contact owners of foreclosed properties offering to obtain money remaining after their land's auction.

***

  • "As foreclosures have increased, we've seen an uptick in get-rich-quick schemes that prey on those who have lost their homes," McKenna said. "This new law is part of our ongoing efforts to help financially-strapped families keep the little money they have left."

***

  • The group's legislative chair, Lewis County Treasurer Rose Bowman, said in a statement that firms charging property owners exorbitant fees was a growing problem. "We were looking for a way to protect our most vulnerable population - people who, for whatever reason, have lost their property to tax foreclosure - and figure out how we can get their money to them and not to others who are trying to claim it," Bowman said. Bowman added there is no need for residents to even use outside help to get surplus funds returned to them. All that is needed is a notarized from, and a notary at the county will provide the service for no charge, she said.(1)(2)

For the story, see Washington AG gets finder-fee cap in foreclosure cases.

For the Washington State Attorney General press release, see New law protects families in foreclosure.

(1) According to the state AG's press release, individuals who provided such services previously kept as much as 50-70 percent of the former homeowner’s money; Bowman added that many of the “finders” use shady tactics, including hounding the original homeowner to sign a paper or trying to convince county officials that they are a relative of the original homeowner, and therefore entitled to the money. “It’s amazing the lengths they go to try to intercept these funds,” she reportedly said.

(2) In May, 2009, the Washington Attorney General's office won a civil jury verdict which hammered a foreclosure rescue operator whose activities allegedly included the snatching of foreclosure surplus funds due to homeowners after they lost their homes in tax sales. The jury found that the business practices engaged in by the operator violated the state Consumer Protection Act. See Washington AG Scores Big Win In Bogus Equity Stripping, Land Trust/Sale Leasebacks & Surplus Ripoffs; Foreclosure Rescue Operator Tagged For $4.2M.

Wednesday, November 11, 2015

Ten Years After Losing Home To Tax Foreclosure, Ex-Homeowner Scores Unexpected Payday By Collecting The Surplus Funds Generated By The Auction Sale That She Didn't Know Belonged To Her

In Buffalo, New York, WIVB-TV Channel 4 reports:
  • Homeowners know if you don’t pay your property taxes, you could lose your home to a tax foreclosure sale. But what thousands of former Erie County property owners don’t seem to understand is, whatever a buyer pays–above and beyond the back taxes–goes back to the previous owner.

    Bottom line: If your home is sold at a tax auction to pay taxes you owe, it is only to ensure the back taxes get paid. But since those properties are sold at auction, the bidding usually takes the final sale price well above the amount of the back taxes.

    Erie County officials believe those surplus funds amount to millions of dollars owed to thousands of former property owners.

    “Crystal” of Buffalo lost her house in a tax foreclosure sale 10 years ago, and just collected her surplus funds two weeks ago.

    The single mother of two grown sons asked us not to use her last name, but was very happy with the big check she got from the State Comptroller’s office.

    Crystal had left her house in the care of friends, to take a job in another state, but they let her down—neglecting to keep up with the taxes and mortgage, which quickly led to a bankruptcy filing, and the house was sold by the city at a foreclosure auction in 2005.

    “I didn’t know what to do, so I just took the advice of others and it didn’t go very well,” Crystal recalled. But fast forward to 2014, and she learned, in a letter, the foreclosure sale had a silver lining.

    “Just a random letter, and I didn’t believe it. I thought it was a scam. So I kind of put it aside and left it there.”

    That letter was from a local business known as a “finder”, or “searcher” that scours the Internet for unclaimed funds and unclaimed property all over the country, and it turned out Crystal had a substantial amount of money—she is keeping the amount to herself–in the New York State Comptroller’s Unclaimed Funds account.

    But Crystal needed the help of Paulette Cooke, an attorney for the Western New York Law Center (1) to get those surplus funds–her money–from the sale of her home. It requires a court order.

    “Once the bidder pays the money, the city taxes are paid, the county taxes are paid, and then that money left over is the surplus money, and the old property owner is entitled to that money.”

    But before Crystal’s money was turned over to the state, city officials turned over her funds–and the surplus funds owed thousands of other former property owners–to the Erie County Comptroller’s office, where the money is held in an unclaimed funds account for 5 years.

    Why does the county hold onto all that money, instead of giving it to the former homeowners? Comptroller Stefan Mychajliw said, they have no way of contacting a foreclosed owner like Crystal, because all they get from the city is a list of addresses, a court order, and a check for the surplus funds.

    “Even if we went to that address, obviously the person is no longer living there. We can go to every single address on that list, but because they were evicted and the house was sold, they are obviously not even there anymore.”

    Mychajliw said, the county is holding about $14 million in unclaimed funds from tax auctions, mortgage foreclosures, and other legal proceedings, which the government is not allowed to touch.

    After 5 years, the county turns the money over to the state, which can make it even tougher to claim. Theoretically those unclaimed funds can remain with the State Comptroller’s Office forever, if it is not claimed by court order.

    The Western New York Law Center is offering to help homeowners who recently lost their homes through tax foreclosure sales, and former homeowners who are owed surplus funds from tax sales. The Western New York Law Center can be contacted by phone at 855-0203, ext. 118.
Source: Foreclosed homeowners could be owed millions from tax sales.

(1) Western New York Law Center is a non-profit law firm providing legal representation to low-income Western New Yorkers in civil matters.

Monday, August 29, 2011

Clerk Of Court Issues Plea To Foreclosed Cook County Property Owners To Come Forward, Claim Their Cash; Says $16M In Sale Surplus Sits Unclaimed

In Chicago, Illinois, the Chicago Sun-Times reports:
  • About $16 million is sitting in a Cook County court fund, just waiting for the rightful owners — namely home and business owners who lost their property to foreclosure, officials said Thursday.


  • The money is part of a mortgage foreclosure surplus fund — profits generated when foreclosed property is sold for more than what the original owner owed the bank.


  • Nearly 2,000 property owners have an average of $2,000 coming to them from foreclosures that date back to the 1990s. Amounts range from 13 cents to $460,000 owed to a business, Brown said.


  • For two years, Clerk of the Circuit Court Dorothy Brown has been trying to get the word out to former property owners to call her office or go to her website and use the search engine to see if they have money coming to them.


  • By state law, her office maintains the account. But having had only marginal success in finding those to whom money is due, she announced Thursday that a task force of city, county and state officials is working on a better marketing strategy. “We need to find a better way, even a more effective way to get the word out,” Brown said Thursday at a news conference with other elected leaders.

***

  • “A lot of people just don’t look back” once they lose a property, she said. “They don’t leave a forwarding address because they have creditors” seeking payment.


  • To see if you are owed mortgage surplus funds, call Brown’s office at (312) 603-5030 or go to [Cook County Mortgage Foreclosure Surplus Search].

For more, see Property foreclosed? Cook Co. hold $16M in fund waiting to be claimed.

See also, Chicago Tribune: Cook Co. reaching out to those due money after property foreclosure ("Brown noted that her office contacted one homeowner who was owed a $200,000 surplus. The homeowner never returned the call.").

Monday, December 07, 2015

Buffalo Lawmakers Amend Proposed Local Law To Limit Money Grab Of Tax Foreclosure Sale Surplus Funds To Non-Owner Occupied Houses; Foreclosed Homeowners To Have Multiple Notification Rights & Right To Claim Cash Overage From Sales In Perpetuity

In Buffalo, New York, The Buffalo News reports:
  • A bill sponsored by State Sen. Timothy M. Kennedy and Assemblyman Sean M. Ryan to give the City of Buffalo millions in surplus money from its annual property auctions has been amended to require the city to notify the foreclosed property owners that the money belongs to them.

    Also, under the revised measure, the city would only be able to claim excess proceeds from the sale of nonowner-occupied properties.

    The change comes after a story in the Nov. 26 editions of The Buffalo News revealed that $11.6 million in excess proceeds auctions, going back to 2009, sit unclaimed, and the city does not tell owners they are entitled to the money.

    The two Buffalo Democrats announced the changes to the legislation on Wednesday.

    “We weren’t aware of the notification problems,” Kennedy said. “With any legislation, as you find things out, you make changes.”

    If the amended legislation passes, the city will have to notify property owners before and during the foreclosure process of the possibility of surpluses and their right to claim them. And when a property is auctioned off, the city then would have to inform the former owner of the selling price and any leftover money, Kennedy said.

    Assemblyman Michael P. Kearns also announced similar legislation but with a caveat: The notification should be retroactive to 2009. “I believe it’s still the responsibility of the city to let those people know about the money as well,” he said. Additionally, he is calling for a simplification to the lengthy legal process to claim the surplus, which can take months.

    The city supports the changes to the Kennedy-Ryan bills but even if they fail, “we’ve said previously the city will take steps to notify in the future,” said Mike DeGeorge, the city’s spokesman.

    Common Council President Darius Pridgen said the Common Council will adopt a resolution in the coming weeks to improve the city’s handling of surplus money from foreclosure auctions. “I think we are all going down the same road. We’re all on the same page,” Pridgen said.
    ***
    Changing the law would put Buffalo on par with Rochester and other cities that are diligent about notifying homeowners of surpluses. But those cities have had local laws that govern their foreclosure processes since the mid 1990s when the state allowed municipalities to create their own. While Rochester and Syracuse implemented their own statutes, Buffalo opted for the state’s guidelines, which do not address surplus funds. So going back to the early 1980s when it began holding in-rem auctions annually, Buffalo has not notified property owners about surplus money.
    ***
    Ryan said the original bill was well-meaning but needed clarification. Owners who lose their primary residence to foreclosure would continue to be able to claim their money in perpetuity. But leftover money from the sale of nonowner-occupied properties would become the city’s after five years.

    “The focus is still irresponsible landlords but we want to strike a balance so family members aren’t unjustly penalized and slumlords don’t continue to abuse the system,” he said.

    Also on Wednesday, the Western New York Law Center(1) announced that it has launched a program to provide free legal assistance to homeowners who are trying to claim surplus money from their properties. The center can be reached at 855-0203, Ext. 124.
For more, see Bill amended to tell foreclosed property owners they are due money (Revised bill frees surplus money).
--------------------------
(1) Western New York Law Center is a non-profit law firm providing legal representation to low-income Western New Yorkers in civil matters.

Wednesday, December 02, 2015

Buffalo Sits On $11.6 Million (& Growing) Pot Of Unclaimed Cash Representing Surplus Funds From Tax Foreclosure Sales That Ex-Homeowners Are Entitled To But Unaware Of; One Unwitting Homeowner Can Claim Almost $150K; Two State Lawmakers Currently Conniving On Proposed Law To Snatch Proceeds On Behalf Of City If Loot Goes Unclaimed For Five Years

In Buffalo, New York, The Buffalo News reports:
  • There is an $11.6 million pot of money that could be divided among people whose properties were sold at Buffalo’s tax foreclosure auctions over the last five years.

    But the city never told these people that the money is there for them to claim.

    And two state lawmakers are now proposing legislation that would allow the city, not the former property owners, to keep this money.

    Once a year, properties in Buffalo are auctioned off when their owners fail to pay taxes. In recent years, these auction prices have skyrocketed, exceeding the tax debt owed. And when that happens, the excess money can be claimed by the foreclosed owners and any lienholders. But no one is telling them. The pot of money has accumulated to the tune of $11.6 million and stands to grow substantially when 2015’s excess proceeds are added next year.

    Thousands of former property owners have no idea about these funds. Right now, this money eventually ends up going to the state, though property owners still retain the right to file a claim. But State Sen. Timothy M. Kennedy, D-Buffalo, and Assemblyman Sean M. Ryan, D-Buffalo, as part of an initiative addressing urban blight and slumlords, are trying to pass legislation that would redirect the money to the city. What’s more, the former property owners would lose their right to claim the money once it’s sent to the city.

    The legislation has picked up the support of key Common Council members.

    If the bill passes, it could mean a windfall for the city’s weatherization and home-improvement program. Previous attempts to pass similar legislation since 2008 failed.

    But it also could mean hard-luck city residents such as Colleen Parker, who already lost her home in the tax lien sale last year, would lose their rights to claim funds. She was unaware – until The Buffalo News told her – that her former home netted a $92,742 surplus.

    “Why would the city not tell people or notify us in some way?” the 57-year-old woman asked. “The city doesn’t know the struggles we’re going through.”

    Parker is getting by on workers’ compensation and disability payments. “It’s already embarrassing and hurtful to lose something you’ve worked so hard for, and then for the city to sock you in the stomach again by not telling you about the money,” she said. “It’s a double whammy.”

    Warren Kubiak, 67, a retired corrections officer, is another former property owner with money to claim. He tried to sell his home on the market and had a buyer, so he got an apartment. But the buyer backed out at the last minute.

    “I couldn’t afford the house and the apartment,” he said.

    It was foreclosed last year and sold at auction, but he was not notified of the $45,333 surplus.

    The sale prices at auction have gone through the roof in recent years. Speculators, investors and immigrants seeking low-cost housing have turned the auction into a high-stakes event, with homes that would have gone for $5,000 in the past fetching $40,000 and more.

    In 2009, a slate of 826 properties sold for $4.6 million at the auction. Five years later, 808 properties yielded $9.2 million.

    After the properties are auctioned, the city withholds money for outstanding taxes, issues payments for county tax and utility liens, then deducts administrative and other fees. Whatever is left is transferred to the county comptroller, who handles all unclaimed funds in the county.

    “We almost serve as a minimal pass-through,” said Erie County Comptroller Stefan I. Mychajliw Jr. “We try our best to make sure that people recover the money that are due to them.”

    If the auction money is unclaimed for five years, it is turned over to the State Comptroller’s Office and becomes a part of the general fund. Even then, claims can still be made through the County Clerk’s Office.

    By law, the money belongs to the parties with recorded interest in the property – the former owners, lienholders and judgment creditors of all kinds. But the same law doesn’t require the city to tell these stakeholders.

    So it doesn’t.

    “We don’t notify formally as part of the process,” said Timothy A. Ball, the city’s corporation counsel. “If someone calls and asks, we will point them in the right direction. Our focus has been on helping people save these properties on the front end and providing mechanisms to avoid foreclosure.”

    Currently, $11.6 million sits in an escrow account – excess proceeds from the auctions held in 2009 to 2014 – from the sale of 1,211 properties.

    The average amount is $9,600. One former owner can claim almost $150,000.

    Only 11 percent, or $2.56 million, has been claimed for the sale of 153 properties out of 1,368 sold at auction since 2009.

    The city’s silence has nurtured a fertile market for “asset locator” companies that charge to unite people with unclaimed assets.

    “All of my clients learned about their surplus from solicitation letters they received from these downstate companies,” said Daria L. Pratcher, a local real estate attorney. “It seems that’s the way most people find out they are entitled to these funds.”

    But their finders’ fees often range from 15 percent to a third of the money.

    The Western New York Law Center(1) provides free assistance, but Paulette D. Cooke, a staff attorney, can only count three or four surplus clients over the last few years. “People just don’t know,” she said. “It’s unfortunate because in most cases, these are people who could really use the money.”

    The city might not be the only municipality mum about leftover money.

    Former suburban homeowners are missing out on almost $3 million in surplus funds from Erie County’s similar pot of money, and those funds also are tended by the comptroller and destined for Albany after five years.

    Mychajliw said he has considered creating a surplus database and will work with lawmakers to better notify foreclosed homeowners.

    And starting next year, city officials said the surplus information will be included in the six to eight foreclosure notices sent to homeowners.

    “We’re always looking to improve the process,” Ball said.

    Government officials are cautious about creating a false sense of hope or giving unscrupulous owners a profitable way to dump properties. Although 40 percent of auctioned properties yielded surpluses last year, the other 60 percent did not. Furthermore, the foreclosed owner is last in line for excess funds. Lienholders, such as banks and mortgage companies, and credit card companies holding judgments have first claim and could seek all of it, depending on the amount of the surplus and debt.

    Kennedy and Ryan have been at war with big banks behind the foreclosures on abandoned “zombie” homes, as well as slumlords and their dilapidated properties. But the rights of foreclosed owners could become collateral damage.

    Their first legislation calls for code violations on non-owner-occupied homes to become tax liens. If that property is foreclosed on, a second bill directs any excess proceeds from that sale and all sales at the auction to the city instead of the state.

    If that law passes next year, it would go into effect immediately. So surplus funds from the 2010 auction will be transferred to the city.

    “Rather than let this money continue to be swept up by bureaucratic Albany, our legislation would ensure that the funds would stay right here in Buffalo,” Kennedy said. “If unclaimed after five years, they would no longer be diverted to the Capitol, but instead would be directed towards the city’s Urban Renewal Agency, which focuses on helping responsible homeowners with weatherization, home repairs and community development.”

    The tandem legislation was announced and touted last May. Council President Darius G. Pridgen and members of Project Slumlord were on hand for the news conference. Lovejoy Council Member Richard A. Fontana drafted matching resolutions that were adopted in May by the Council.

    The city and Council members said they didn’t know the amount of the surplus. Pridgen said he was unaware of the city’s lack of notification to property owners but is committed to improving the process.

    The list abounds with city residents who fell on hard times. Job loss, divorce, bankruptcy or other changes in their financial situation led to foreclosure.

    Take Yvonne Young, who bought a fixer-upper on Connecticut Street for only $4,100. Repairs on the home were constant and beyond her budget, so Young, along with her two children, moved in with her then-boyfriend, who is now her husband.

    “As a single mother, it was hard trying to keep up,” she said. “I put so much money into that house and tried my best. But there was always something that needed to be fixed. And it just became too much. There was nothing I could do.”

    The house sold for $70,000 in 2012. The surplus she’s entitled to is about $64,000.

    “That’s incredible, so surreal,” Young said. “I can’t even speak. There’s so much I could do with that money. But I won’t believe it until I can actually get it.”
Source: $11.6 million left unclaimed from home auctions (Buffalo residents who have undergone tax foreclosures not told of surpluses).

See also: Homeowners hammered by foreclosure are also losing out on auction profits, where The Buffalo News editorial board calls for local government officials to make greater efforts to track down the unwitting homeowners who are unaware that, while they may have lost their home to foreclosure, they may have a pot of money awaiting them, a pot that constites the amount by which the auction sale price exceeded the amounts owed to the foreclosing entity (ie. the surplus funds, or sale overage).

The editorial board also effectively gives a "thumbs-down" on the idea that the local government should simply help themselves to the loot and use it for the city weatherization and home improvement program for low-income residents.
-------------------------------------
(1) Western New York Law Center is a non-profit law firm providing legal representation to low-income Western New Yorkers in civil matters.

Friday, August 17, 2007

NJ AG, Consumer Affairs File Suit Against "Foreclosure Surplus" Chaser

From the office of the New Jersey Attorney General:
  • "The [NJ] State Attorney General's Office and the Division of Consumer Affairs have filed suit against a Gloucester County businessman who allegedly collected tens of thousands of dollars in surplus funds that homeowners otherwise would have received for a small fee after their homes were sold in foreclosure. The state's two-count complaint against Samuel E. Goodwin, III is the first action filed under the state's Consumer Fraud Act to address deceptive practices in the area of surplus funds recovery. Goodwin allegedly charged homeowners 15% to 65% of the total surplus funds to which they were legally entitled by misleading the homeowners into believing that the process to recover the funds was complicated and could not be filed by the homeowners on their own."

In New Jersey, defaulting homeowners whose homes sell at a foreclosure sale auction for more than the amount owed to the foreclosing mortgage lender (Editorial Note: currently uncommon in many areas given today's real estate market conditions; but was happening with tremendous frequency as recently as two years ago) can reportedly claim the excess or surplus funds (Editorial Note: subject to the claims of secondary lienholders) by filing a simple form available from the Superior Court Trust Fund Unit and after paying nominal fees totaling less than $100.

For more, including how a New Jersey resident can file a complaint with the state if they were subjected to a surplus funds scam, see NJ Attorney General Press Release - State Files Suit Against South Jersey Businessman Who Allegedly Engaged in Deceptive Practices Against Homeowners in Foreclosure.

Thursday, October 21, 2010

Colorado AG: Sale Leaseback Peddler Stripped $1M+ In Equity By Targeting Financially Unsophisticated, Vulnerable Homeowners In F'closure Rescue Racket

Courthouse News Service reports:
  • Jason L. Lynn, now of Marion, Ohio,(1) and his company, Superior Financial Group, of Superior, Colo., defrauded people through "unlawful foreclosure consulting services," the Colorado attorney general claims in Denver County Court.(2) The state filed a similar complaint against Patrick Brunner, Jerry Ohu, Gregory Hoffman, William Schultz, Fortune Financial Group, and Platinum Financial Group, in the same court.(3)

Source: Foreclosure Scams (5th story from top).

For the lawsuit, see State of Colorado v. Lynn, et ano.

(1) According to the lawsuit, Lynn was a resident of Colorado until in or around September 2009, at which point it appears that he decided to skip town. The AG has tracked him down residing, upon information and belief, at 975 Champagne Drive, Marion, Ohio 43302, the suit states.

(2) According to the lawsuit, the Colorado AG seeks to permanently enjoin Defendants, including Jason L. Lynn, individually, from engaging in deceptive trade practices, to obtain civil penalties and restitution, to disgorge unjust proceeds, and to recover attorney fees and costs. The suit alleges violations of the Colorado Consumer Protection Act, C.R.S. §§ 6-1-10 1 6-1-1120, and further alleges that Lynn is a "foreclosure consultant" within the meaning ofthe Colorado Foreclosure Protection Act, C.R.S. §§ 6-1-1101 to 6-1-1120.

The following excerpt from the Colorado AG's lawsuit (paragraphs 23-31) sets forth the general allegations made against Lynn (bold text is my emphasis, not in the original text):

  • 23. Beginning in 2005 and continuing through 2007, Jason Lynn, acting through his company Superior Financial Group, LLC, targeted financially unsophisticated and vulnerable Colorado homeowners in foreclosure and obtained more than $1,000,000 of equity through unlawful foreclosure consulting services involving sale-leaseback schemes. Lynn executed this scheme through the use of disparate bargaining power and inadequate disclosures. Homeowners not only lost all their equity to Lynn but in some cases their homes to eviction.

    24. Lynn promised victims that they could save their homes from foreclosure by selling them to Lynn's investors and then leasing the home from the investor for two years with an option to repurchase it. Upon information and belief, nearly all the homeowners were unable to repurchase the home, in part because significant amounts of equity were stripped from the home for Lynn's personal use and to compensate his investors, and the repurchase price was therefore unreasonable.

    25. Rather than provide meaningful assistance to homeowners, Lynn obtained substantial equity from the homeowners at closing without disclosing the amount and purpose of the sales proceed assignment to Lynn.

    26. Through advertisements on television and in newspapers and through referrals, Lynn targeted financially unsophisticated and vulnerable homeowners who had significant equity in their homes as a result of lengthy ownership, but nevertheless faced foreclosure because of economic hardship or personal tragedy.

    27. Lynn induced these homeowners to sell their homes to avoid a foreclosure sale, stay in their longtime homes, and have a opportunity to resume ownership. Some of the homeowners had spent many years, and some decades, in their homes and wanted to remain and once again repurchase their homes--and where thus susceptible to Lynn's deception and predatory conduct.

    28. After determining the amount of equity that could be obtained based on the existing mortgage and the estimated value, Lynn approached homeowners with a sale contract and a lease agreement containing an option to repurchase the property. Homeowners were not allowed to negotiate the sale price of their home or the repurchase price. Rather, Lynn misled the homeowners to believe that working with Superior Financial Group, LLC was the best way to save their home. Through deceptive, false, and misleading conduct, Lynn induced the victims to sign the sale contract and lease agreement.

    29. Lynn promised the victims that once they sell the home, they would remain in the home as a tenant with the option to repurchase the home when their credit or financial condition improved. Lynn informed the victims that he would use the equity from the sale, which was transferred at closing to Superior Financial Group, LLC through a proceed assignment, to assist the homeowners with rent payments and repairs. At no time, however, did Lynn disclose the actual purpose or amount of the proceed assignment. Moreover, he did not disclose that he himself would use the homeowner's equity for his personal use.

    30. At the closing, the homeowner victims would assign, without warning or disclosure, all the equity in their home through a proceed assignment to Superior Financial Group, LLC, which was presented to them for the first time at the closing.

    31. Lynn obtained equity from the victims up to $106,994 per transaction. The victims not only lost substantial equity in their homes as a result of this scheme, but many also lost the homes when they were evicted or forced to leave when the investor allowed the home to go into foreclosure.

-------------------------

This type of foreclosure rescue scam is the kind of title transfer where the deed conveying title that has been successfully attacked in Colorado through application of the state consumer protection statute, and has led to an award of triple damages on behalf of the victimized homeowner. See Appeals Court Reverses $3M+ Jury Award To Equity Stripping Victims; Homeowners Forced To "Settle" For Triple Damages ($741K) Under State Consumer Fraud Act.

A successful attack on a sale leaseback scam perpetrated on a homeowner could also conceivably result in the voiding of the mortgage loan that financed the equity stripping scam upon a finding that the lender is not entitled to the protection of the state recording statutes as a bona fide purchaser due to its failure to inquire of the occupants of the property that were in open possession thereof into any unrecorded rights and/or equities they may have.

See, for example, Martinez v. Affordable Hous. Network, Inc., 123 P.3d 1201; 2005 Colo. LEXIS 1075 (Colo. 2005), in which the Colorado Supreme Court applied the bona fide purchaser doctrine in a sale leaseback, foreclosure rescue scam:

  • It is well settled in Colorado that, with certain exceptions inapplicable here, possession of real estate is sufficient to put an interested person on inquiry notice of any legal or equitable claim the person or persons in open, notorious, and exclusive possession of the property may have. See Hitchens v. Milner Land, Coal & Townsite Co., 65 Colo. 597, 601, 178 P. 575, 576 (1919);  Colburn v. Gilcrest, 60 Colo. 92, 94, 151 P. 909, 910 (1915);  Yates v. Hurd, 8 Colo. 343, 344, 8 P. 575, 576 (1885);  Tiger v. Anderson, 976 P.2d 308, 310 (Colo.App.1998).

Such a result was recently achieved in a recent Minnesota case applying the applicable state consumer protection statute involving a similar fact pattern. See Minn. Sale Leaseback, Equity Stripping Victim Wins Back Free & Clear Home With Help From Non-Profit Law Firm As Judge Voids Sale & Subsequent Mortgage.

(3) Attorneys General in Massachusetts, Arizona, Maryland and Washington State have enjoyed recent success in bringing civil lawsuits prosecuting sale leaseback foreclosure rescue peddlers by invoking their respective state consumer protection statutes, See:

The New Jersey Attorney General's Office has also brought civil lawsuits in sale leaseback cases which are currently pending:

The Feds, state and local law enforcement authorities have all brought criminal prosecutions in equity stripping, sale leaseback cases cases involving the use of third party investor/straw buyers in the process of pocketing the equity out of a victim's home. See, for example, the following posts for the year 2010:

It goes without saying that if there was any fraud committed by Jason Lynn in obtaining the mortgages for his straw buyer investors in his Colorado civil case, he makes for a nice juicy target for a criminal prosecution by the Colorado Feds.

Monday, October 05, 2009

Jury Says St. Pete-Area Foreclosure Rescue Operator Liable For Duping Financially Strapped Homeowner Into Signing Over Home Under Guise Of Help

In Sarasota, Florida, the St. Petersburg Times reports:
  • In a "groundbreaking'' case that could be the first of its kind in the nation, a jury this week found that the owner of a St. Petersburg foreclosure rescue company scammed a 60-year-old Port Charlotte woman out of her home. The Sarasota County jury awarded $93,467 to Wanda Costa, who unwittingly sold the house to Gideon Rechnitz for nothing in 2006 even though she had substantial equity at the time. Under the guise of helping her, Costa's lawyers said, Rechnitz and associate Thomas Cook duped her into signing over the deed without making it clear she would still be responsible for the mortgage and thousands of dollars in "commissions.''(1)

  • "What the jury did in this case was say 'No' to that kind of behavior,'' said attorney Elizabeth Boyle of Gulfcoast Legal Services, which represented Costa for free. "I hope other people will come forward because they may get some relief, too.''

***

  • As fraud proliferates, there has been a growing number of cases nationwide in which judges ruled in favor of homeowners who claimed they were cheated out of their property.(2) Boyle said her research indicated that Costa's case may the first in which a verdict was rendered by a jury. The nonprofit National Consumer Law Center said it did not know if there have been jury verdicts elsewhere.

For more, see Jury finds Rechnitz defrauded widow of her home in a foreclosure scam.

(1) According to the story, Rechnitz, the subject of several St. Petersburg Times articles, is among scores of individuals and foreclosure prevention companies under investigation by Florida Attorney General Bill McCollum.

(2) After a six day bench trial, the Office of the Washington State Attorney General similarly secured a significant award (nearly $4.2 million) from a foreclosure rescue operator peddling sale leaseback deals to, and running alleged "foreclosure surplus snatching" scams on, financially strapped homeowners. The operator entered into transactions with more than 300 property owners, and no one ever successfully regained their home from him, according to the state AG's office [see Pay time for notorious foreclosure rescue scammer (Attorney General announces major victory in state’s case with Washington man who promised help but took homes)].

  • “Kaiser’s victims were elderly, disabled or low-income individuals – people who trusted him to solve their foreclosure problems and were betrayed,” [Prosecuting attorney James] Sugarman said. “Kaiser portrayed himself to these people as an expert in saving homes facing foreclosure, when he is actually an expert in taking homes facing foreclosure.”

For more, see Washington AG Scores Big Win In Bogus Equity Stripping, Land Trust/Sale Leasebacks & Surplus Ripoffs; Foreclosure Rescue Operator Tagged For $4.2M.

Monday, December 21, 2015

Phones Ring Off Hook At Buffalo Non-Profit Law Firm Since News Broke Of $11.6 Million In Unclaimed Surplus Funds Belonging To Ex-Homeowners From Past Foreclosure Sales

In Buffalo, New York, The Buffalo News reports:
  • The Western New York Law Center has been inundated since news broke of $11.6 million in surplus auction money that foreclosed owners can claim, but the city never told them about.

    Hundreds of calls poured into the nonprofit after a Nov. 26 Buffalo News story revealed the staggering balance from Buffalo’s property auctions, from 2009 to 2014, in an account managed by Erie County Comptroller Stefan I. Mychajliw Jr. The average amount is $9,600; the highest is almost $150,000.

    But the law doesn’t require the city to give surplus notifications, and after five years the money goes into the state’s general fund. Only 11 percent, or $2.56 million, has been claimed for the sale of 153 properties out of 1,368 with surpluses since 2009.

    Now the word is out, more previous owners are coming forth, anxious to claim the money. But it’s an involved legal process since some properties might have lienholders and judgments, and those creditors have first dibs on the surplus. A State Supreme Court judge decides its rightful owner.

    The law center’s assistance is free, so city residents, like Yvonne Young, have been calling.

    “I’ve been assigned a lawyer, and I’m so excited to get the process started,” said Young, who is expecting the entire $64,535 left from the sale of her West Side home in 2012 since a title search yielded no lienholders or judgment creditors. “I can’t believe it and won’t believe it until I have the money.”

    The law center’s surplus case load grew tenfold from last year’s in just two weeks. A new surplus hotline had to be created to handle the calls.

    As of Monday, 31 cases had been validated using the Buffalo News property auction surplus database and 39 more are being processed as the phone continues to ring.

    “It’s really picked up; we’ve definitely been busy,” said Paulette Cooke, a staff attorney at the law center.
    ***
    “What about the people who lost their homes years ago? How are they supposed to know,” asked Colleen Parker, a 57-year-old Buffalo resident, whose home was sold in the 2014 auction but learned of the $92,742 surplus from The Buffalo News. “Not everyone reads the paper or watches the news. How will they know?”

    April Reynolds, a 45-year-old Buffalo resident, didn’t know until Thursday that $13,149 remains from the 2012 sale.

    “A surplus? I haven’t heard anything about this,” Reynolds said. “All I can say right now is wow.”

    The law center is launching an outreach campaign next month that will probably employ investigative online tools to find the previous owners or their heirs since their current addresses are unknown. Assemblyman Michael Kearns, D-Buffalo, is drafting legislation, with the center’s assistance, to require notifications be retroactive to 2009. It calls for “extraordinary efforts” to find and unite owners with the money but also allows municipalities to charge surplus accounts “reasonable fees” to cover notification costs, he said.

    ***
    Meanwhile, local private law firms are on a separate and profitable pursuit to also find surplus claimants.

    “They’ve got the list too and have been calling me to find out how to file the claims,” Cooke said. The comptroller’s office has also received a number of requests for the list from law offices.

    “They think it’s a gold mine, and plan to track down previous owners,” Cooke said, “but some charge 30 percent of the surplus money.”

    Claimants can to take their cases to a private firm, but the law center’s services are free, Cooke added. The center’s surplus hotline is 855-0203, Ext. 124.
For more, see Law Center flooded by foreclosure calls (Former owners seek excess auction money).

Tuesday, July 11, 2017

Reversing Earlier Trial Judge's Ruling, Florida Appeals Court Nixes Attempt By Winning Bidder At Foreclosure Auction To Snatch Away Sale's Surplus Proceeds From Foreclosed Former Homeowner

In Marion County, Florida, the Florida Record reports:
  • A case involving property owners who claimed a lower court incorrectly paid out surplus funds following a foreclosure has been remanded to a lower court, according to a recent opinion from the 5th District Court of Appeal.(1)

    The case began when Federal National Mortgage Association (FNMA) foreclosed on the property owned by Carlos M. Rodriguez and Rafael Rodriguez. The property was subsequently sold to Luzupozo LLC after the final judgment. There weren’t any lienholders listed in the case, according to court records.

    Funds remained with the court clerk after FNMA’s judgment was satisfied. The clerk gave the Rodriguezes and their assignee, National Equity Recovery Services (NERS), the surplus funds within 60 days, court documents state. More than 60 days after that, Luzupozo requested that the court releases the surplus to pay liens from FNMA’s mortgage.

    The trial court granted the request that Luzupozo should receive the extra money, according to court records.

    The Rodriguez family and the NERS appealed the judgment.

    The appeals court in its ruling cited Section 45.032 of Florida Statutes, which defines the owner as "as the person who appears to be the owner of the property 'that is the subject of the foreclosure proceedings on the date of the filing of the lis pendens'" and says the property owner should receive “surplus funds after the payment of subordinate lienholders who have timely filed a claim.”

    Based on this, the appeals court said the court clerk should hold the surplus pending a court order within 60 days of providing disbursements. If the owner claims the amount during that time, the court should pay it to the owner, less any relatable service charges.

    The appeals court wrote the Rodriguezes were considered the owners, and there were no subordinate lienholders so the Rodriguezes were entitled to the surplus.

    The appeals court reversed the lower court’s decision and remanded the case so the surplus amount would go back into the court system for additional proceedings.
Source: Florida appeals court sends case involving surplus funds to lower court.
-----------------------
(1) Rodriguez v. Federal National Mortgage Association, Case No. 5D17-196 (Fla. App. 5-DCA, June 23, 2017).

Monday, May 13, 2013

Ex- Homeowner Who Lost Home To Foreclosure Nearly 20 Years Ago Discovers He May Be Victim Of Recently-Revealed NYC Surplus-Snatching Scam

In Brooklyn, New York, WNYC News reports:
  • William Easterling and his wife used to own 165 Forbell Street, a two-family home in Brooklyn on the border of Cypress Hills and Ozone Park. The couple raised their four kids there. But they haven’t lived there in almost 20 years.

    Easterling had been violently mugged on his way to work in 1992 and his wife said, "enough." They moved. But his troubles didn't end there. He had to file for bankruptcy and was forced to surrender the Brooklyn property.

    What he didn't know was that his old property was listed in the indictment against Senator John Sampson, who's accused of keeping money that came from the foreclosure sale.

    He also didn’t know that years ago he may have had a right to claim some of the $80,000 Sampson reported from the sale of 165 Forbell Street.

    “Otherwise I would have the attorney looking into it with all the money I had to spend, plus with the money I lost in the home,” he said. “But I had no idea, no.”

    Sampson is accused of embezzling $440,000 from the foreclosure sales of four properties. In each case, he was appointed by the courts to serve as the referee. In that role, he was overseeing the foreclosure auction and making sure that any surplus funds were returned to the Kings County clerk for disbursement. Sampson is accused of keeping that money for himself. He has pleaded not guilty to the charges.

    Josh Zinner, co-director of NEDAP, a nonprofit that works on economic justice issues, says the extra money from foreclosure sales often represents the families' leftover equity — and possibly their only source of wealth after they had lost their homes in foreclosure.

    Easterling thinks someone should have told him there was money out there owed to him.

    “I'm 70 years old, okay. I wasn't born yesterday. I mean I look in the mirror and I don't think I look that stupid,” he said. “If I should have been owed something, I feel like it should have been up to the court to inform me.”

    A spokesman for the Office of Court Administration admitted there is no system in place to make sure referees actually deposit surplus funds from a foreclosure sale to families. And, technically, it wasn't up to the court to notify Easterling.

    Even if Easterling had known he should claim it, prosecutors are saying, the money wasn't there to give. Sampson allegedly kept it.(1)
Source: Sampson Corruption Scandal Hits Home for One Family.

(1) According to the indictment, by helping himself to the surplus proceeds, Sampson, an attorney, allegedly violated a fiduciary duty to the Brooklyn Supreme Court. If true, and if the funds ultimately cannot be recovered, and assuming that only licensed attorneys can act as court-appointed referees in New York, it may be that the violation of this duty may be enough to enable the court, as well as the ultimate victims (ex-homeowners and subordinate lien holders of the four foreclosed homes) to recover some or all of the pilfered proceeds from The Lawyers’ Fund For Client Protection Of the State of New York, the state's attorney ripoff reimbursement fund.

For information on "attorney ripoff reimbursement funds" in other states and Canada, see: